Turkey Hill Ice Cream Flavors List: 37 Best Picks Ranked for 2025
Are you searching for the best Turkey Hill ice cream flavors to share at the next birthday party, anniversary celebration, holiday gathering or midnight snack session? Have you tried any of Turkey Hill ice cream’s many flavors? For sundaes, floats, milkshakes or a big bowl of frozen happiness, Turkey Hill is an affordable brand with a wide selection of flavors.
Turkey Hill started as a milk route during the Great Depression. After the founder’s children took over in 1947, they began churning out ice cream in the 1950s with simple favorites like chocolate, vanilla and fruit. By the ’70s, they were experimenting with Southern pecan pie and eggnog, and the lineup has continued to grow ever since, adding inventive ice creams, sherbets and iced teas.
Beyond ice cream, Turkey Hill partners with conservation groups to protect local waterways and dairy farms. Through the Turkey Hill Clean Water Partnership (THCWP) — formed with the Alliance for the Chesapeake Bay and the Maryland & Virginia Milk Producers Cooperative — the company funds conservation plans that keep the Chesapeake Bay, the Susquehanna River and surrounding farms healthy.
According to a local THCWP farmer, “The health improvement we have seen in our calves and heifers has been huge simply due to the new facilities and better environment that we now have. If the farmer does not get financial aid, many of these projects will not continue.”
Are you a devoted member of Team Vanilla or do you like to explore unique flavors and creative combinations? Check out this Turkey Hill ice cream flavors list to discover your next favorite flavor.
Jump to Section
37 Best Turkey Hill Ice Cream Flavors
1. Cookies ‘n Cream
This Turkey Hill ice cream flavors list starts with one of the company’s most popular flavors. Cookies ‘n cream is made with artificially flavored vanilla ice cream and swirls of chocolate wafer cookie crumbles. It has 150 calories per 2/3 cup serving and makes an excellent choice for birthday parties, anniversaries, holiday events and any Netflix binge session you might encounter.
2. Strawberries & Cream
If you’re craving the flavors of fresh strawberries and sweet cream, you’ll want to run right out and pick up a carton of this Turkey Hill ice cream flavor. It offers a sweet combination of strawberry ice cream and slices of fresh strawberries. Mix it in with ginger ale and a drizzle of grenadine to create a tasty Shirley Temple float. This flavor has 130 calories in a serving.
3. Peanut Butter Ripple
Are you searching for a peanut butter-inspired flavor mixed with something other than chocolate? You’re in luck! This Turkey Hill ice cream flavor is made with vanilla ice cream and a lovely ribbon of gooey roasted peanut butter. It has 170 calories per serving and makes a great choice for floats, milkshakes and on its own.
4. Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
We can thank Vermont-based Ben & Jerry’s for the goodness that’s known as chocolate chip cookie dough. One of the world’s most popular desserts in the freezer section, this Turkey Hill ice cream flavor is prepared with cookie dough flavored ice cream, cookie dough and chocolate chips.
If you’ve ever licked the spoon a little too long after whipping up a batch of cookies, this is the flavor for you. It has 160 calories in a serving and is a popular choice for any birthday party, holiday event or late-night snack session.
5. Black Cherry
Filled with delicious chunks of black cherries, this Turkey Hill ice cream flavor is a refreshing choice for a sundae, pie topping or a unique milkshake. The bittersweet flavor of the cherries blends perfectly with the sweet and creamy vanilla ice cream. There are 130 calories in a serving of this Turkey Hill ice cream flavor.
6. Butter Pecan
Are you searching for a sweet treat with a crunchy finish? The butter pecan Turkey Hill ice cream flavor is described as being like vanilla but with a buttery outlook and hints of nuts. It’s made with butter pecan ice cream and filled with roasted pecan pieces. It has 160 calories in a serving and is excellent in a cone, cup or banana split.
7. Fudge Ripple
Made with a simple combination of vanilla ice cream and rich fudge swirls, fudge ripple is one of the most popular flavors in the freezer section or scoop shop. This Turkey Hill ice cream flavor has 140 calories per serving. Enjoy it in a cone topped with whipped cream, brownies and caramel sauce.
8. Black Raspberry
Are you a fan of fruity flavors? Black raspberry is right up your alley. It’s made with black raspberries (a distant relative of the more familiar red raspberry) and a puree made with red and black raspberries to create a beautiful purple color and a distinct fruit flavor. This Turkey Hill ice cream flavor has 130 calories in a serving.
9. Original Vanilla
If you’re searching for a classic Turkey Hill ice cream flavor, you can’t go wrong with original vanilla. Vanilla’s ability to serve as the base for a variety of frozen treats makes it a favorite for birthday parties, holidays and other special events. Use for fried ice cream, apple pie à la mode or in a classic Boston cooler, a refreshing float made with ginger ale and ice cream. At 170 calories, it features the traditional vanilla flavor everyone loves.
10. French Vanilla
For a rich take on the simplicity of vanilla, check out French vanilla Turkey Hill ice cream. Similar to the French custard ice cream style, it does contain eggs. It has 180 calories per serving and offers a creamier take on the classic vanilla flavor. Whip it into a frothy milkshake or serve with a fresh peach cobbler or apple pie.
11. Simply Natural Homemade Vanilla
Turkey Hill’s Simply Natural line is made with a short list of simple and natural ingredients like milk, sugar, vanilla and cream. The homemade vanilla variety has nonfat milk, vanilla beans and 200 calories per serving. It’s a wonderful option for banana splits, ice cream cakes or topped with sprinkles, chocolate chips and fresh fruit. Other Simply Natural flavors include mint chocolate chip, strawberries & cream, salted caramel and Belgian-style chocolate.
12. Colombian Coffee
If Juan Valdez were in the ice-cream-making business, this Turkey Hill ice cream flavor would be at the top of his production list. You can get your coffee fix with this blend of coffee ice cream and roasted Colombian beans. With 130 calories per serving, it’s been described as being similar in taste to an affogato.
13. Dutch Chocolate
Turkey Hill’s Dutch chocolate flavor is made with Dutched cocoa, which is darker, smoother and milder than traditional chocolate. The process is attributed to an actual Dutch chocolate maker, Coenraad Johannes van Houten (not to be confused with the German heritage of Pennsylvania Dutch country). Hershey’s “Special Dark” is an example of chocolate made using the Dutch cocoa process. If you prefer the flavor of dark chocolate in your milkshakes and brownie sundaes, this is the Turkey Hill ice cream flavor for you.
14. Triple Chocolate Trio’politan
When you just can’t decide which chocolate you’re craving, but you know you want chocolate something, you’ll want to check out the triple chocolate trio’politan. With 150 calories, this Turkey Hill ice cream flavor consists of a chocoholic trio of milk chocolate with a fudge swirl, dark chocolate and Dutch-style chocolate with chocolate chips.
15. Chocolate Lava Cake
This Turkey Hill ice cream flavor is prepared with dark chocolate swirled with fudge and chocolate cookie bar pieces. It has 180 calories per serving. It’s a rich and decadent limited-edition flavor to choose when you’re craving an indulgent chocolate fix.
16. Moose Tracks®
Moose Tracks® is one of the best Turkey Hill ice cream flavors for fans of vanilla ice cream and swirls of peanut butter cups and Moose Tracks® fudge. At 190 calories per serving, it’s a tasty choice for a hot fudge sundae or scooped into a waffle cone and drizzled with caramel or chocolate.
17. Orange Cream Swirl
For that classic creamsicle bar flavor, dig into a container of orange cream swirl. Made with vanilla ice cream and swirls of orange sherbet, this Turkey Hill ice cream flavor has 150 calories per serving and delivers a fresh take on frozen treats. Use it in a creamsicle float or serve with a slice of lemon meringue pie.
18. Late Night Salted Caramel Chocolate Espresso
This line of Turkey Hill ice cream flavors uses decadent ingredients to calm your late-night cravings for salted caramel, soft cookies, rich chocolate chunks and buttery batter-inspired flavors. The salted caramel chocolate espresso flavor features a rich and indulgent 300-calorie blend of mocha chocolate ice cream, chocolate espresso chips and a swirl of sea salt caramel.
19. Late Night Cherry Chocolate Chunk
Another Late Night Turkey Hill ice cream flavor, this one is made with cherry-flavored ice cream and filled with pieces of cherries and chocolate chips. At 270 calories per serving, you can serve a scoop with cherries jubilee, Black Forest cake or fluffy angel food cake.
20. Late Night Brownie Batter Cookie Dough
You don’t have to whip up a mix of brownie batter or cookie dough to enjoy this delicious treat. It’s already all mixed in there. Brownie batter flavored ice cream is filled with chocolate chip cookie dough pieces and a cookie crumb swirl. Other Late Night flavors include buttery Southern pecan pie, ultimate cookie overload and chocolate peanut butter cup. This Turkey Hill ice cream flavor has 310 calories in a serving.
21. Choco Mint Chip
One of the most popular Turkey Hill ice cream flavors, Choco Mint Chip is made with mint ice cream with chocolate chips. It has 200 calories per serving and lots of chocolate chips mixed into fresh and minty ice cream. Enjoy a big scoop in a bowl, bake into a minty baked Alaska or combine with a trio of flavors on your next banana split.
22. Rocky Road
Turkey Hill’s rocky road is made with Dutch-style chocolate and filled with roasted almonds and marshmallow swirls. This Turkey Hill ice cream flavor has 160 calories and is a terrific option for milkshakes, served with slices of pecan pie or scooped into a crunchy waffle cone. It does contain almonds and eggs, so be aware of any allergies or dietary restrictions.
23. Late Night Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup
One of the best Turkey Hill ice cream flavors, chocolate peanut butter cup blends chocolate ice cream with roasted peanut butter. Whether you’re a fan of sweet chocolate or salty peanut butter, this flavor will cure both cravings. There are 170 calories per serving in this Turkey Hill ice cream flavor.
24. Strawberry Marshmallow
In collaboration with Barbie™, this Turkey Hill ice cream flavor features a pretty in pink mix of strawberry ice cream and marshmallow fluff. Some ice cream fans have mentioned that it could use more marshmallows, but it’s certainly pretty enough for a sundae, topped with sparkly sprinkles or combined with other flavors on a dessert bar. This Turkey Hill ice cream flavor has 140 calories per serving.
25. Frosted Cupcake
Another Barbie™ collaboration on the sweet side, frosted cupcake is perfect for a Sweet 16 soiree, a baby shower or a tea party dessert table. It’s made with cupcake-flavored ice cream and swirls of pink icing and has 170 calories in a serving. Pick up a carton of this Turkey Hill ice cream flavor the next time you’re looking for a sweet and sassy treat.
26. Chocolate Marshmallow
This Turkey Hill ice cream flavor is the chocolate version of strawberry marshmallow. Chocolate ice cream is accented with swirls of fluffy marshmallows. This rich flavor has 150 calories and is a wonderful choice for plopping into a mug of hot chocolate or topping with colorful sprinkles, whipped cream and caramel drizzles.
27. Graham Slam
From the Majors and Minors to the local Little League, summer baseball games are the perfect opportunity to indulge in the sweet and tasty Turkey Hill ice cream flavors. Made with artificially flavored graham crackers, marshmallow-filled chocolate cups and a graham cracker swirl, this seasonal flavor pays homage to summer’s favorite sport with its pinstriped baseball packaging. It comes in at 200 calories per serving.
28. Pistachio Almond
Are you searching for a unique Turkey Hill ice cream flavor for an ice cream cake or to serve with a peach cobbler, crisp cookies and soft brownies? Pick up a carton of pistachio ice cream with crunchy almonds. This fun flavor has 140 calories per serving.
29. Deep Dark Chocolate
For Turkey Hill ice cream flavors ranked high on the rich and decadent scale, pick up a pint of deep, dark chocolate. At 210 calories, this flavor is made with deep, dark chocolate ice cream and a scattering of chocolate chips. It adds a double dose of chocolate flavor to any birthday party, holiday gathering, Netflix binge-watching or late-night snacking session.
30. Pumpkin Pie
This seasonal Turkey Hill ice cream flavor is a favorite of pumpkin lovers everywhere. Made with pumpkin-flavored ice cream with a cinnamon graham cracker swirl, you can pair it with your pumpkin spice latte for an extra punch of pumpkin goodness. It has 180 calories per serving and makes a delicious pumpkin ice cream roll, cake filling or accompaniment to warm apple pie.
31. Frosted Party Cake
Which Turkey Hill ice cream flavor makes a sweet and colorful addition to a birthday party? A frosted party cake is prepared with artificially flavored vanilla ice cream filled with pieces of cake and blue icing swirls. An excellent choice for a sweet 16 celebration or served with pastel frosted cupcakes, this flavor has 160 calories per serving.
32. Neapolitan
If you can’t decide on a single flavor, go with three traditional flavors to please the whole group. Neapolitan is a neat and colorful collection of strawberry, chocolate and vanilla bean ice cream slices. This Turkey Hill ice cream flavor has 170 calories in a serving and is perfect for making ice cream sandwiches, sundaes and banana splits.
33. Tin Roof Sundae
Get your chocolate-covered peanut fix with this Turkey Hill ice cream flavor. Prepared with vanilla ice cream and filled with rich fudge and chocolate-covered peanuts, it has 160 calories per serving. It features a sweet and creamy flavor profile with a salty edge that’s perfect for when you’re in a sundae kind of mood but don’t feel like investing in the whole sundae-making experience.
34. Double Dunker
Double Dunker is prepared with mocha ice cream with cookie dough swirls and chocolate sandwich cookie crumbles. This Turkey Hill ice cream flavor has been described as a flavor blend of coffee, chocolate chip ice cream and cookies and cream. It has 190 calories and 10 mg of caffeine per serving.
35. Vanilla Salted Caramel
It doesn’t get much better than the simplicity of vanilla and caramel. This Turkey Hill ice cream flavor is made with vanilla ice cream and swirls of salted caramel and has 140 calories per serving. Top with chocolate-covered pretzels, peanut butter chips or caramel sauce for an extra decadent cone.
36. Peaches and Cream
If you’re looking for a refreshing seasonal flavor for spring and summer picnics and backyard barbecues, this limited-edition Turkey Hill ice cream flavor is calling your name. It’s prepared with peach-flavored ice cream and filled with peach swirls and pieces of juicy peachy goodness. This flavor has 130 calories per serving. Serve with fluffy angel food cake, peach cobbler or a slice of blueberry pie.
37. Eggnog
Another seasonal favorite, this Turkey Hill ice cream flavor is full of eggnog, rum and spicy nutmeg flavors. It has 140 calories per serving and makes a tasty addition to a boozy milkshake, a slice of pumpkin pie or scooped into a big bowl and topped with whipped cream, cinnamon and crumbled sugar cookies.
How Many Flavors of Ice Cream Does Turkey Hill Have?
Now that we’ve covered questions concerning “What ice cream flavors does Turkey Hill have?” we’ll get into just how many classic, custom, fruity, rich and refreshing flavors there are. Turkey Hill makes more than 50 delicious flavors. Sign us up for a taste-testing session! You can find your favorite Turkey Hill ice cream flavors at stores like Walmart, Food Lion and more.
Does Turkey Hill Have Dairy-Free Ice Cream?
With Turkey Hill’s commitment to family farms, the dairy industry and local ingredients, you’ll find an ingredient list filled with fresh milk, cream and more. What you won’t find is a dairy-free version. Milk is a source of potassium, protein, magnesium and vitamin D. It contributes to strong bones and teeth, muscle function, blood clotting, heart health and more. Unless you’re lactose-intolerant, enjoy Turkey Hill ice cream flavors with moderation.
Does Turkey Hill Have Sugar-Free Ice Cream?
So, does Turkey Hill make sugar-free ice cream? There is a no-sugar-added vanilla bean Turkey Hill ice cream flavor. It’s made with fat-free vanilla-flavored ice cream and vanilla bean specks. At 100 calories and zero fat, it’s an alternative if you’re seeking low-calorie sweet treats, but it does contain milk.
If you’re looking for ways to enhance your love of the Turkey Hill brand and conduct your own review of Turkey Hill ice cream flavors ranked by taste, take a trip to the Turkey Hill Experience at the Conestoga manufacturing facility. You’ll learn all about milk, cows and the ice cream-making process (along with samples of ice cream and iced tea).
According to the Turkey Hill website, “At Turkey Hill, we make family fun more delicious. We use a pinch of creativity and a dash of joy in all our flavors — because life, like your treats, should be sweet and packed with fun.”
For even more ways to explore your favorite foods, check out other experiences happening on Cozymeal.
FOOD FOR THOUGHT?
Join the conversation.