Tillamook Ice Cream Flavors List: 21 Best Picks Ranked in 2025

If you’ve ever strolled through the frozen foods section at a grocery store, you may have noticed the vast, brightly-colored variety of Tillamook ice cream flavors on sale. Maybe you were intrigued enough to stop and pick one up; perhaps you were just freezer-window shopping — but whatever the case, those unreasonably large cartons more than likely caught your eye.

This is unequivocally a good thing: whether you went in for it or not, it got one of the best ice cream brands on the market onto your radar. So, when you're ready to make a purchase, how do you know which Tillamook ice cream flavors are worth the investment? To help you answer that question, we’ve assembled this Tillamook ice cream flavor ranking. 

No matter what the flavor, though, Tillamook is renowned for its smooth texture and quality ingredients compared to other supermarket ice cream brands, so you can’t really go wrong. With that being said, let's dive into this list of the most popular Tillamook ice cream flavors and help you find your next go-to scoop.

Jump to Section

• How Many Flavors of Ice Cream Does Tillamook Have?
• The 21 Best Tillamook Ice Cream Flavors Ranked

How Many Flavors of Ice Cream Does Tillamook Have?

The Tillamook ice cream flavors list currently includes 35 delectable choices, including limited edition products such as Apple Crisp and Salty Caramel Pretzel. This number is constantly changing, though, with new flavors being released fairly regularly and others dropping off.

If you're familiar with the brand, you'll know that you can shop for products that range from deliciously simple to daring and creatively inventive. However, if you're new to the world of Tillamook ice cream flavors, you can expect everything from Chocolate and various forms of Vanilla (which, according to NASBA, is the most popular ice cream flavor) to Campfire Peanut Butter Cup and Tillamook Mudslide.

The brand has also mastered the culinary art of ice cream sandwiches, with five flavors currently on offer: Chocolate Mudslide, Mint Chocolate Chip, Oregon Strawberry, Salted Caramel and Vanilla Bean.

The 21 Best Tillamook Ice Cream Flavors Ranked

21. Chocolate Peanut Butter 

Chocolate and peanut butter pair well because of the salty-sweet contrast they create when combined, so it’s no surprise that this distinction is the strong point of this Tillamook ice cream flavor. Tillamook gets the balance of flavors right, and everything harmonizes beautifully.

That said, the chocolate flavor definitely comes through more strongly than the peanut butter, so if you’re hoping for the ice cream version of a Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup, you may be in for a surprise. On the whole, though, this Tillamook ice cream flavor is still absolutely worth the buy.

20. Rocky Road 

Rocky Road has long been the flavor of choice for people who want big, chunky mix-ins with their ice cream. With added nuts and marshmallows, you won't be desiring any extra toppings with this Tillamook ice cream flavor.

However, if you’re not a nut fan, you may not find that to be to your liking. Rocky Road nets a slightly lower rating for being a little less broadly appealing than other flavors — it’s not mind-blowing enough to overcome your almond aversion. That said, it’s a solid rendition of the flavor that Rocky Road fans will be delighted with.

19. Chocolate Chip 

If you like gelato, another popular dessert that differs to ice cream in the slightest of ways, you’re likely familiar with the merits of stracciatella. This quintessential gelato flavor is a subtle and refined combination of delicate vanilla and shaved chocolate.

That’s pretty much what this Tillamook ice cream flavor is trying to do, and it succeeds. Chocolate Chip might not be the choice for you if you favor flashy or inventive flavors, but it’s unassuming, delicate, not too much — sometimes you want that. More than plain vanilla but not weighed down by chunky mix-ins, Chocolate Chip is an underrated way to experience Tillamook’s signature flavor without (as much of) a sugar rush.

18. Coffee Almond Fudge 

It’d be hard to find two flavors more divisive in the ice cream world than almond and coffee. Is the bitterness of coffee complex and fascinating or unappetizing in an ice cream? Do you love nuts in your ice cream or hate them? So it’s impressive that this Tillamook ice cream flavor incorporates both and is so well loved. 

That may be because the flavors aren’t too intense, though. While the fudge and coffee flavors come through nicely, they’re not too strong. If you’re skittish about coffee, that may be welcome news. It is delicious — there’s no denying that — but if you’re looking for a really punchy coffee-flavored product, this Tillamook ice cream flavor might not be it. 

17. Neapolitan

You’d be surprised how easy it is to mess up a Neapolitan ice cream. A bland vanilla, watery chocolate or chemically strawberry flavor can quickly derail this complex flavor. So we’re thrilled that Tillamook offers a version that won’t disappoint. 

All three elements making up this Tillamook ice cream flavor (Vanilla, Chocolate and Oregon Strawberry) are ranked much higher on this list, and you’ll get the same deliciousness here. It’s only ranked a little lower because, frankly, Neapolitan isn’t everyone’s thing. However, though a lack of popularity might weigh down its ranking, this Tillamook ice cream flavor is still as delectable as you’d expect.

16. Mountain Huckleberry 

Tillamook hails from Oregon, and many of its fruit flavors pay homage to the state's rich tradition of berry farming (Mountain Huckleberry isn’t the last you’ll see on this list). That results in products you won’t see any other brands producing, like this Tillamook ice cream flavor. 

While it’s not the brand’s most popular berry flavor, Mountain Huckleberry is a lovely choice. Tart huckleberry jam is swirled into classic vanilla ice cream; cliché as it sounds, it’s sort of like pie à la mode. Does it shine next to some of its berry counterparts? Not always, but this Tillamook ice cream flavor still delivers the delectable taste of smooth vanilla mixed with tangy berries.

15. Caramel Swirl 

It’s indicative of the level of competition we’re looking at here that a Tillamook ice cream flavor like Caramel Swirl doesn’t even crack the top ten. It hurts to do it, sure, but at a certain level, there’s just not a lot separating the rankings. So please don’t give the number more weight than it deserves. 

Caramel Swirl is a dream come true if you happen to love caramel: there’s nothing more to it than vanilla ice cream and a creamy caramel ribbon throughout. It’s a strong enough flavor to stand alone but not too overpowering, so it pairs exceptionally well with apple desserts. 

14. Cookies and Cream 

Let’s cut to the chase: this Tillamook ice cream flavor is a bit light on the “cookies” part. That said, it’s a fan-favorite in spite of that. Many lament that lack of mix-in density not because the flavor is lacking, but precisely because it’s already so good: how much better would it be if there were chunks of copycat-Oreo in every single bite? 

Any Tillamook ice cream flavor that begins with French Vanilla has a strong start already, and the chocolate cookie pieces have a subtler and more wholesome taste than other ones you might be used to. If it were a little more cookies than cream, it would almost surely be in the top five. 

13. Dark Chocolate Cookies and Cream

Take everything we just said about Cookies and Cream and imagine an identical Tillamook ice cream flavor that uses chocolate as a base instead of vanilla. That is quite literally all Dark Chocolate Cookies and Cream is. But dare we say it actually tops the original? 

Because the main shortcoming of the Cookies and Cream Tillamook ice cream flavor is its lack of mix-ins, a base with a stronger flavor works well. The chocolate adds interest that otherwise might not be there and distracts a little bit from the paucity of cookie pieces. 

12. Chocolate 

If you really commit to doing them right, you can’t beat the classics. And Tillamook always commits to doing it right, so you can be sure that their Chocolate ice cream is going to be excellent. Creaminess is the name of the game with Tillamook ice cream flavors, and this one is no exception.

With chocolate, the pitfall to avoid is that bland, watery flavor we all dread; this Tillamook ice cream flavor easily dodges it. It’s everything you want in chocolate ice cream and nothing you don't. That said, there are more interesting Tillamook ice cream flavors, so even this excellent Chocolate is going to have a tough time climbing much higher than this in the ranks. 

11. Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough 

Sometimes, one kind of dessert simply isn’t enough. And sometimes, you need baked goods with your ice cream. On that day, give this Tillamook ice cream flavor a try: it does a stellar job satisfying both of these requirements.

The base is simple — the classic vanilla you’d expect. The cookie dough bites are soft, chewy and moreish, with just the right amount of chocolate chunks to provide a nice crunch. Cookie dough is best when it’s most skillful in its use of textures, and this Tillamook ice cream flavor is masterful indeed. A great pick on a summer evening when you’re hankering for cookies but can’t bring yourself to turn on the oven.

10. Udderly Chocolate

Udderly Chocolate marks the first appearance of white chocolate in any of the Tillamook ice cream flavors on this list. Frankly, it’s all too easy for the sweetness of white chocolate — uncut by any tart, bitter or salty notes — to become cloying, so that’s saying a lot. This flavor succeeds at using white chocolate well because it’s balanced with a more complex chocolate ice cream, as well as chocolate chips.

The resulting combination is a richer and more complex Tillamook ice cream flavor than you’d ever expect. While this product might have succeeded more if the white ice cream were plain old vanilla, that doesn’t mean that Udderly Chocolate doesn’t reach the rare achievement of making so many glad to be eating white chocolate. 

9. Mint Chocolate Chip 

Don’t pick up a carton of this Tillamook ice cream flavor expecting a bright julep green. The lack of food dye makes it closer to white than green, but don’t let that put you off: it’s chock-full of chocolate, and the mint flavor comes through clearly in spite of the color. Sharp but sweet and perfectly proportioned, this Tillamook ice cream flavor is a mint chip for grown-ups. 

8. Oregon Strawberry 

When it comes to strawberry desserts, you’re constantly navigating perilous terrain. There are few things better than a ripe summer strawberry, but the minute you start trying to recreate that flavor in a lab, you’re edging towards dangerous territory. And that is why Tillamook’s Oregon Strawberry is such a big win. 

Why is that? This popular product contains real strawberries — make no mistake about that. The appeal of this Tillamook ice cream flavor lies in that fact: it isn’t faking anything. Rather than a vague taste of chemicals, you’ll be getting a bright, sweet mouthful of authentic strawberry flavor with every bite. Gone are the days of icy, neon-pink strawberry scoops — this Tillamook ice cream flavor is doing it right.

7. Caramel Toffee Crunch 

We’ve got lots going on here: toffee, almonds, pecans, a caramel ribbon — you’re not going to be wanting for mix-ins with this Tillamook ice cream flavor. On top of that, the base for this isn’t the standard vanilla or chocolate, but caramel! Tillamook pulls out all the stops with this flavor, which is why it's loved by so many. 

There are some people who might find all those mix-ins to be a bit much. We’re not denying that: it’s a busy flavor, and the simplicity of the original flavors might get a bit lost in the shuffle. But isn’t that exactly why you buy a Tillamook ice cream flavor like this? A lot of flavors to take note of keeps a scoop of ice cream interesting.

6. Marionberry Pie

And now, the crowning glory of Oregonian berry-inspired Tillamook ice cream flavors. A marionberry pie is transplanted almost whole into a vanilla ice cream base, with pie crust chunks and marionberry jam to complete the blend. It’s a quintessentially Oregonian dessert that translates to the medium of ice cream better than you’d think. And even if you think you’re not into fruit flavors, you’ll find something to love about this — guaranteed. 

So what exactly is a marionberry, you may ask? It’s a hybrid blackberry species that was first cultivated in Oregon in 1948. Expect a flavor much like blackberry, but a little more intense. It’s not a common fruit to find on supermarket shelves or ice cream menus, which makes this Tillamook ice cream flavor all the more special. 

5. Waffle Cone Swirl 

No ice cream cones? No problem — just put them in the ice cream. This Tillamook ice cream flavor isn’t the first to attempt a cones-mixed-in concept, but it’s definitely the best.

Chocolate and vanilla ice creams are a perfect base for salted caramel swirl and crunchy waffle cone pieces, and it all comes together as well as you’d hope. You might be skeptical about cones as a mix-in, but give this Tillamook ice cream flavor a shot anyway. That extra crunch is actually its secret weapon. 

4. French Vanilla 

You can be contrary about it all you like, but vanilla is a classic flavor for a reason. Not only does its mild sweetness complement just about any other flavor beautifully, but a delicious vanilla ice cream is outstanding all on its own. Boring? Not if the maker pays close attention to the details that make vanilla delicious. And you’ve probably guessed by now that Tillamook absolutely nails it. 

A great vanilla has to be light but dense, creamy but not heavy. More than any other flavor, it has to taste like the real deal — vanilla suffers noticeably when it has an artificial aftertaste. It can’t taste overpowering, but it can’t be bland, either. And this simplest of Tillamook ice cream flavors hits all of those notes. If you’re going to buy vanilla ice cream, do yourself a favor and make it Tillamook. 

3. Peaches and Cream 

Fruit-flavored ice creams can be dicey, often bringing a chemical aftertaste to the table that nobody really enjoys. But this Tillamook ice cream flavor is a near-perfect demonstration of how good they can be when done well.

Because Tillamook uses real fruit in this flavor (both in the form of peach chunks and a peach swirl), it tastes deliciously natural and makes for the ideal summer dessert. Craving peach cobbler in weather that’s too hot for baking? This Tillamook ice cream flavor might be your answer.

2. Tillamook Mudslide 

Tillamook does simple flavors well, but it also excels at mix-ins. This busy but incredible Tillamook ice cream flavor ought to convince you of that. You wouldn’t think that a chocolate ice cream base would need chunks and a fudge ribbon, but you’d be surprised: when it comes to Tillamook Mudslide, more is more! 

If you’re a hardcore chocolate fanatic, this Tillamook ice cream flavor will be pretty much unbeatable for you. It’s rich and fudgy, and offers an interesting combination of textures, which keeps the chocolate from feeling too one-note. An absolutely stellar flavor for anyone, but especially for the kind of person who doesn’t think plain chocolate ice cream can be improved upon. Spoiler alert: It can, and it has. 

1. Brownie Batter

There was always going to be a hot debate about what made the coveted #1 spot on this list of the best Tillamook ice cream flavors. Everyone’s got their thing, and passionate fans have passionate opinions — but ours is that this somewhat unassuming flavor ought to get the nod. Why? It succeeds where so many similar brownie flavors fail.

You see, there’s an art to brownie-flavored ice cream. Since brownies can easily turn into barely chewable hunks of dough when frozen, finesse matters immensely. Few brands have perfected the art of keeping brownies soft and chewy in their ice cream, but this one has. Tillamook’s signature smoothness and high fat content complement that perfect brownie just as you’d hope it would. If you love a good brownie, this flavor is a triumph. 

This Tillamook ice cream flavors list had to exclude a few worthy picks, but that only speaks to how incredible the brand's lineup is. Quality and texture are amazingly consistent across flavors, and much of this ranking comes down to things like popularity and personal preference rather than quality or execution.

That ought to tell you just how high Tillamook’s standards are. So, whatever you decide to snag on your next supermarket run, it won’t do you wrong.

For even more ways to explore your favorite foods, check out other experiences happening on Cozymeal.