Talenti Ice Cream Flavors List: 41 Best Picks Ranked for 2025

Talenti ice cream flavors bring creative and gourmet twists to traditional favorites. Their website explains how they do this – “Talenti uses an old-world process that involves slow cooking our ingredients and making our gelato in smaller batches than most other ice cream in the U.S. is made.” So, what exactly distinguishes gelato from regular store-bought ice cream? 

While you may be correct in assuming that gelato is the Italian word for ice cream, as an expert from the Institute of Culinary Education explains, “When a gelato base is churned, it doesn’t have much air whipped into it. This gives it a very dense texture and a richer mouth feel. Think about that when you purchase your next scoop of ice cream – 50% of what you’re buying is air.”

This lower fat content in gelato in general and Talenti ice cream flavors, in particular, is what makes each scoop a more intense tasting and satisfying experience. Now that you have had the quickest lesson on the advantages of premium ice cream making, let’s get to the fun part – the tasting! Following are 41 of the best Talenti ice cream flavors available today.

Jump to Section

• 41 Best Talenti Ice Cream Flavors
• What Flavors of Ice Cream Does Talenti Have?

41 Best Talenti Ice Cream Flavors

1. Cold Brew Coffee Sorbetto

This Talenti ice cream flavor features a bold blend of Brazilian and Colombian cold brew coffee, offering a rich coffee taste without any hint of milk. It's especially popular among those with lactose intolerance, providing a delicious way to enjoy a coffee fix without dairy. While some may find it a bit too sweet, coffee lovers are likely to appreciate its deep, intense flavor.

2. Summer Strawberry Sorbetto

This sorbetto offers a refreshing taste of fresh strawberries with a hint of lemon, creating a delicate balance between sweet and sour. The popularity of this Talenti ice cream flavor stems from the rich, natural strawberry flavor that shines through in every mouthful. The addition of lemon may not appeal to everyone, as its tartness can be a turn-off for some.

3. Roman Raspberry Sorbetto

A Talenti ice cream flavor that features a tangy raspberry base with just a hint of lemon, striking a perfect balance between tart and sweet. It's especially popular among fruit lovers who enjoy the refreshing taste of fresh raspberries. Keep in mind that the bold tartness may be a bit overwhelming for some.

4. Zesty Lemon Sorbetto

Bright and zesty, this dairy-free Talenti ice cream flavor offers a blend of real lemon juice and zest combined to create a sweet and zesty dairy-free sorbetto. Light and refreshing with a smooth texture, this sorbetto has just the right amount of lemony zing, which makes it a popular choice. However, some prefer more bite and acidity.

5. Alphonso Mango Sorbetto

The delicious sweetness of mangoes combined with a hint of lemon makes for a compelling flavor. Made from the freshest mangoes from Maharashtra, India, the richness of the fruit spreads through every bite, making this Talenti ice cream flavor a popular choice. It's important to note that the lemon flavor can sometimes detract from the natural sweetness of the mangoes.

6. Belgian Chocolate Gelato

A creamy gelato with all the richness of Belgian chocolate and just a hint of vanilla, this Talenti ice cream flavor is a decadent treat. Rich and creamy Belgian chocolate blended into a smooth gelato takes this to a whole new level, making it a favorite among chocolate lovers. This Talenti ice cream flavor is extremely chocolaty, so non-chocolate fans may not appreciate the taste.

7. Sea Salt Caramel Gelato

The goodness of homemade dulce de leche comes through with every bite, with caramel truffles adding to the intense flavor. As one of the most iconic Talenti ice cream flavors, it’s a decadent and delicious, smooth treat for the senses. However, some people seem disappointed with the lesser amount of truffles added.

8. Caribbean Coconut Gelato

The fresh and tender coconut taste in this gelato will wow you, though the name is a bit misleading, as the coconuts are sourced from the Philippines. Fresh milk, cream, sugar and vanilla combined with tender coconut make this evergreen Talenti ice cream flavor favorite a winner. Some find the coconut flavor underwhelming, but you'll love it if you're into this kind of fresh taste.

9. Double Dark Chocolate Gelato

Chocolate morsels and a dash of vermouth come together to create a uniquely rich gelato. The intense double chocolate taste makes this Talenti ice cream flavor a favorite, with some fans even suggesting it be renamed “Death by Chocolate.”  Keep in mind that the addition of vermouth isn’t for everyone and may not appeal to all palates.

10. Southern Butter Pecan Gelato

The caramel flavor of the dulce de leche combined with the crunch of roasted buttery pecan nuts is just what’s needed to lift your mood. The texture and nutty flavor the pecans bring to the caramel make this Talenti ice cream flavor a favorite, though some reviewers say the amount of pecan nuts needs to be increased.

11. Mediterranean Mint Gelato

A real taste of mint extracted from mint leaves, along with star anise and chocolate chips, makes this an unusual take on classic mint ice cream. The strong taste of mint paired with the chocolate chips creates a very refreshing flavor, which is why this Talenti ice cream flavor is popular. Some feel the amount of chocolate chips is a little less than expected, but it keeps the flavor in the right balance.

12. Pacific Coast Pistachio Gelato

Reminiscent of the classic Sicilian pistachio, this Talento ice cream flavor now uses roasted Californian pistachios instead. By combining roasted pistachios with pistachio butter, the nuttiness comes through as strong and pleasing without being overpowering, making it a popular choice. However, when it comes to Talenti ice cream flavors ranked, not everyone agrees that the new recipe is as good as the original.

13. Caramel Cookie Crunch Gelato

A delicious sweet cream gelato with chocolate cookies blended in and a swirl of dulce de leche, this Talenti ice cream flavor offers a rich and satisfying experience. The caramel flavors in this combination make it one of the most popular of Talenti’s offerings, though some fans sometimes demand an even higher caramel content.

14. Coffee Chocolate Chip Gelato

Rich flavors of Brazilian and Colombian coffee combine with the taste of semi-sweet chocolate chips in this bold gelato. Anyone who likes their coffee with a bit of chocolate will love this Talenti ice cream flavor. This gelato may be too sweet for some, and the quantity of chocolate chips is often seen as woefully inadequate, but it's a great choice for coffee lovers.

15. Madagascan Vanilla Bean Gelato

A rich and unique vanilla taste extracted from vanilla beans imported from Madagascar forms the base of this gelato, with a dash of lemon zest enhancing the rich vanilla flavor. Rich and creamy, the vanilla flavor is really amped up, making it a standout among Talenti ice cream flavors. Some people prefer the older version that was made using Tahitian vanilla beans, but this option stays among favorites for most Talenti fans.

16. Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip Gelato

Rich black raspberries combined with a burst of chocolate chips create a Talenti ice cream flavor that balances hints of tart and sweet. The irresistible combination of tangy berries, sweet chocolate and the smooth creaminess of gelato has made this Talenti ice cream flavor a true favorite among fans. 

17. Peppermint Bark Gelato

Creamy white chocolate peppermint gelato studded with semi-sweet chocolate chips delivers a burst of cool, refreshing taste in every spoonful. The perfect pairing of crisp peppermint and the goodness of chocolate creates an irresistible festive indulgence, making this Talenti ice cream flavor a popular seasonal favorite. However, it's only available for a few months of the year.

18. Pumpkin Pie Gelato Layers

Pumpkin spice and everything nice come together in this “pie-in-a-tub” icon. Reviews claim it’s the “best dessert in the world,” raving about its perfect sweet-and-spice ratio, the authentic pumpkin flavor, and the delicious crunch of real pie crust. People have spoken — they want more of this Talenti ice cream flavor, with calls for increased stock and bigger tubs next time!

19. Caramel Apple Pie Gelato

Real cinnamon sticks are steeped in milk and cream to create a rich cinnamon-flavored gelato, but Talenti takes it a step further by blending in bits of apple pie — crusts and all — along with caramel. With customers willing to cross state borders for this apple pie à la mode in ice cream form, it’s definitely one of the top Talenti ice cream flavors. Fans wish that this seasonal flavor wasn't available for just a few months each year.

20. Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Gelato

A combination of peanut butter and Belgian milk chocolate oozes from every bite, and with its creamy, buttery texture, this gelato is undeniably addictive. The swirls of peanut butter and the addition of peanut butter cups take this Talenti ice cream flavor to the next level. Some may find it too sweet and there has been feedback that the peanut butter swirls aren’t always mixed evenly with the milk chocolate gelato.

21. Vanilla Fudge Cookie Gelato Layers

Iconic flavors come together in this classic dessert, with extra dark chocolate and super smooth, creamy vanilla. Talenti elevated two of their most popular classics by interspersing cookie chunks and fudge sauce for added crunch and indulgence. It can be hard to get all the layers of this Talenti ice cream flavor in one bite, but it's worth the try.

22. Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Gelato

Vanilla, chocolate chip cookie dough and fudge come together in one predictably delicious combination. Sustainably sourced cocoa beans give this popular Talenti ice cream flavor an added edge and make it a feel-good indulgence

23. Salted Caramel Truffle Gelato Layers

The mix of sweet and salt in this salted caramel creation, combined with layers of chocolate cookies, dulce de leche, vanilla gelato and chocolate caramel truffles, is like being in chocolate-caramel-infused heaven. The sheer decadence of all these layers leaves fans bursting with happiness, making it one of the most indulgent Talenti ice cream flavors. 

24. Peanut Butter Vanilla Fudge Gelato Layers

Peanut butter gelato, peanut butter cups, fudge sauce, vanilla gelato,and peanut butter cookie pieces come together to create a salted peanut buttery dessert with a mix of crunchy, smooth and rich textures. The mini peanut butter cups and the fudgy layer are often praised as the two best parts of this sweet Talenti ice cream flavor.

25. Confetti Cookie Gelato Layers

Your beloved birthday cake is in ice cream form. This Talenti ice cream flavor is sweet and nostalgic and is a great option for non-chocolate-loving fans. Layers of vanilla gelato, vanilla cookie crumbs, sprinkles and a pretty pink cream cheese frosting make it a celebration-worthy treat. However, there seems to be an imbalance in the amount of dry sprinkles compared to the ice cream layers — though if you love sprinkles, that might be a bonus.

26. Coffee Cookie Crumble Gelato Layers

A coffee lover’s dream, this Talenti ice cream flavor is made from cold brew gelato, dark chocolate chunks, vanilla gelato, chocolate coffee sauce and Amaretti cookies — offering plenty of flavors to please almost every palate. The delightful combination of bold coffee notes with the crunch of dark chocolate chunks and Amaretti cookies makes it a fan favorite. 

27. Strawberry Shortcake Gelato Layers

Inspired by strawberry shortcake, this gelato features an unusual yet delightful mix of rhubarb with fresh berries and buttery shortbread crumbs. The eye-catching packaging sets the tone for what's inside — a perfect Talenti ice cream flavor combo of fresh fruit and rich gelato, balanced with a tangy rhubarb sauce that fans of bold flavors may find adds a refreshing twist.

28. Italian Tiramisu Gelato

The gelato here is made with real mascarpone cheese, while the cold brew coffee sorbetto provides the ideal foil for its creamy richness. Add in a layer of espresso fudge sauce and vanilla cookie pieces, and you have a quality dessert sure to please many. A relatively new addition, this Talenti ice cream flavor replicates the light and airiness of an actual tiramisu. While it may not be sweet enough for some or might have a bit too much coffee flavor for younger palates, those who enjoy a more sophisticated, balanced dessert will likely find it just right.

29. Blueberry Crumble Gelato Layers

Oatmilk gelato gets a blueberry zing, complemented by a crumble of muffin and oat crunch that ties it all together beautifully. It’s kosher, non-GMO and dairy-free — and with more than 70 glowing online reviews, it’s clear this Talenti ice cream flavor is very, very delicious. While it’s not a vegan option due to the presence of eggs, it’s still a fantastic choice for those seeking a flavorful dairy-free treat.

30. Vanilla Caramel Swirl Gelato

Everyone’s favorite vanilla meets caramel in this uber-creamy pairing. Customers rave about the texture and rich mouthfeel of this Talenti ice cream flavor, with flecks of vanilla bean and gooey swirls of caramel making for an indulgent treat. Its only drawback? It’s so popular that it often flies off the shelves — so if you spot it, consider it your lucky day!

31. Double Cookie Crunch Gelato

Made with oat milk, this 100% dairy-free gelato carries a welcome nuttiness that sets it apart — some even claim it’s the best non-dairy gelato they’ve ever tasted. With pieces of chocolate cookies and sugar cookie crumbs mixed in, it’s easy to see why this Talenti ice cream flavor is so popular. While it’s not overly sweet, that can actually be a plus for those who prefer a more balanced and subtly indulgent dessert.

32. Chocolate Chip Cookie Batter Gelato

The cookie-to-ice cream ratio is spot on in this Talenti ice cream flavor, featuring buttery shortbread pieces, gooey chocolate chip cookie batter and chocolate cookie pieces woven through their classic Madagascan vanilla gelato. Customers love the natural taste and high-quality ingredients that make this iconic fusion a standout. While it’s a rich dessert that might be best enjoyed in smaller portions, that just means it lasts a little longer — unless you can’t resist going back for more!

33. Caramel Toffee Crunch Gelato

Another dairy-free dazzler from the Talenti ice cream flavors list, this one knocks it out of the park in terms of taste and texture. Smooth cashew-flavored ice cream is studded with almond toffee and swirls of dulce de leche, making it a rich, satisfying treat. Made with cashew butter and 100% dairy-free, it’s a must-try — get your hands on it soon to avoid the fear of missing out! 

34. Snickerdoodle Cookie Gelato Layers

A new winning fusion from the collection, this Talenti ice cream flavor is a delicious take on a cinnamon cookie ice cream sundae. Crunchy, velvety and indulgent, it’s quickly becoming a fan favorite. While the bold cinnamon flavor might not be for everyone, those who enjoy warm, spiced desserts will likely find it absolutely irresistible.

35. Mint Fudge Cookie Gelato Layers

Fresh mint with chocolate cookies and a decadent fudge sauce come together to elevate the classic chocolate mint theme. The chocolate cookie crunch adds a new dimension to the gelato-eating experience, making this Talenti ice cream flavor stand out. While the fudge sauce may not be to everyone’s liking, it adds a rich, indulgent twist that many chocolate lovers will truly appreciate.

36. Raspberry Cheesecake Gelato

A blend of tangy raspberry swirls with cream cheese gelato and graham cracker crumbs, this Talenti ice cream flavor brings all the richness of a classic dessert in gelato form. Real cream cheese is blended into the gelato for a whipped, fluffy indulgence that fans love. While some customers feel the current version doesn't quite match the original —  describing it as tasting more like vanilla with crunchy cookies — others may still enjoy it as a lighter, more subtly flavored take on the classic.

37. Chocolate Cherry Cheesecake Gelato Layers

A layer of cherry cheesecake gelato followed by chocolate chips and black cherry sauce, then another layer of cheesecake gelato topped with graham cookie pieces — this Talenti ice cream flavor delivers a wild combination of textures and tastes. With five layers of goodness and plenty of crunch to complement the cherry cheesecake flavor, this is one you won’t want to put down. While the chocolate chips may be a bit firm straight out of the freezer and it can be tricky to get all the layers in one spoonful, a little patience as it softens makes for an even more enjoyable experience.

38. Key Lime Pie Gelato

There’s purée of real lime in this special “pie-in-disguise” gelato, with one reviewer even comparing it to eating a frozen key lime pie. Dig your spoon deep and you’ll be rewarded with a mouthful of graham cracker bits, tangy lime swirls and creamy gelato. While it’s a seasonal sensation that often sells out quickly or isn’t stocked in every state, the limited availability of this Talenti ice cream flavor only adds to the excitement — making it a true treasure when you do find it.

39. Cookies and Cream Gelato Layers

Your childhood treat of cookies dipped in milk just got a gelato upgrade. Talenti ice cream flavors add their own delicious twist to nostalgia by layering ice cream with dulce de leche and real cookie crumbles. While some may find it a tad sweeter than other flavors, that extra sweetness is exactly what makes it a comforting and indulgent trip down memory lane for dessert lovers.

40. Almond Butter and Honey Gelato

If you like sweet and salty, you’re going to love this one. As one of the special rotational Talenti ice cream flavors, it’s available only between January and April, adding to its seasonal charm. While some may be unsure about the mix of tastes and textures or find it hard to pinpoint a dominant flavor, that unpredictability is part of what makes it a fun and surprising treat for adventurous palates.

41. Old World Eggnog Gelato

A Christmas special that’s sweet and just the slightest bit naughty, this festive Talenti ice cream flavor is perfect for the holiday season. If you like eggnog, you already know to stock up on this indulgent extravagance. While it’s only available between September and December, its limited run makes it all the more special — something to look forward to as the holidays approach each year.

What Flavors of Ice Cream Does Talenti Have?

There’s no simple answer to the question, “What ice cream flavors does Talenti have?” The brand prides itself on creating new and exciting flavors as well as refining and evolving existing favorites. In fact, if you check out Talenti ice cream flavors ranked by experts and enthusiasts, you will notice a wide range that appeals to every palate. 

As of today, you can find fan-favorite Talenti ice cream flavors such as Sea Salt Caramel and Mediterranean Mint among the many varieties on offer. But don’t be surprised if you don’t find these items a few months later.

Some flavors such as Pumpkin Pie, Old World Eggnog, Peppermint Bark and Vanilla Chai are seasonal and available only between September and December. Additionally, there are also special batch flavors with limited in-store availability (known as rotational flavors). Once these are sold out, they are swiftly replaced by a new flavor so keep an eye out or you might miss them. 

Talenti ice cream flavors also feature a range of innovative fruit-forward options such as Roman Raspberry and Lemon Sorbetto, offering a refreshing twist. If you have dietary concerns, the brand boasts a delicious range of dairy-free, egg-free and gluten-free options. In addition to gelato and sorbetto tubs, there are also mini-bar versions and layered frozen desserts among the most popular desserts.   

If you are stuck searching for your favorite flavor, the Talenti website can help you locate the nearest store with it in stock. You can also request a store manager to order your favorite from the Talenti ice cream flavors list or email the company directly for assistance. 

Does Talenti Have Sugar-Free Ice Cream?

Unfortunately, Talenti ice cream flavors do not include a range of sugar-free ice creams. But, we have high hopes that in the future they will deliver on this front as well. In the meantime, you can enjoy a range of flavors that are lower in sugar or the more fruity varieties that are naturally sweet thanks to the freshness and seasonality of the ingredients. It’s always best to check the labels and nutritional information on each product to ensure before choosing the healthiest ice cream that it matches your dietary requirements. 

Does Talenti Have Dairy-Free Ice Cream?

Talenti ice cream flavors boast an excellent selection of dairy-free ice cream options. The brand refers to them as sorbettos. These are 100% dairy-free products that are made with water, sugar and fruit, fruit juice or fruit purée. Some may use oat milk or other plant-based ingredients. Popular flavors include their Dairy-Free Chocolate Fudge and the Alphonso Mango Sorbetto. Again, ensure you check the labels to confirm which flavors are dairy-free before consuming.

To sum it all up, Talenti ice cream flavors offer an incredible selection for anyone with a sweet tooth. You have the classics like Vanilla Bean, Chocolate and Caramel flavors to dig into and if you are more adventurous, you can try out options such as Black Raspberry or Pumpkin Pie. With a rotating and seasonal menu, you are assured of something new throughout the year.

Talenti takes pride in using only the highest quality, non-GMO ingredients, the freshest of fruit and all-natural flavorings. All ingredients used are also OU-D kosher certified as well. And for those with dietary restrictions, never fear, the Talenti range of dairy-free, egg-free and gluten-free options are here to save the day. Without any change in taste or texture, you are assured of the best Talenti ice cream flavors no matter what you choose. 

For even more ways to explore your favorite foods, check out other experiences happening on Cozymeal.