12 Best Sugar-Free Ice Creams To Try in 2025

In recent years, sugar-free ice cream has emerged as a significant trend in the frozen dessert industry, attracting consumers across all age groups who are seeking healthier alternatives to traditional ice cream. This shift is not merely a passing fad but reflects a broader movement towards reduced sugar consumption and more health-conscious eating habits.

This evolution in sugar-free ice cream has attracted a diverse and enthusiastic customer base, from young adults looking to maintain their fitness goals to seniors managing their blood sugar levels. Generally, sugar-free ice cream refers to the treat being free of added sugars. However, there are a few options on the market that have no sugars or only 1 gram per serving. 

But are these sugar-free ice creams truly as satisfying as the real deal? In this article, we'll explore the 12 best low-sugar and sugar-free ice creams available, examining their flavors, textures and nutritional profiles.

Whether you're watching your sugar intake, managing diabetes or simply looking for a guilt-free indulgence, there's likely a no added sugar or completely sugar-free ice cream option that will tickle your taste buds.

 Jump to Section

• The 12 Best Low-Sugar Ice Creams
• What Is the Best Low-Sugar Ice Cream?
• Is Sugar-Free Ice Cream Low Carb?

The 12 Best Low-Sugar Ice Creams

1. Rebel Creamery Mint Chip

Rebel Creamery's Mint Chip flavor stands out in the world of low-carb and sugar-free ice cream options. This keto-friendly treat boasts a creamy texture and refreshing mint flavor with a generous amount of chocolate chips dispersed throughout. Rebel also uses natural sweeteners to achieve a satisfying sweetness without the sugar spike, creating an ice cream with 0 grams of sugar.

What sets Rebel apart is its commitment to maintaining the rich, indulgent taste of traditional ice cream. The high-fat content also contributes to this luxurious texture. However, this also means it's higher in calories compared to some other sugar-free options. Each 2/3 cup serving contains 210 calories and 19 grams of total fat, 16 grams of which are saturated fat. 

2. Braum’s No Sugar Added Ice Cream

Popular ice cream parlor chain Braum’s has a vast array of added sugar-free ice cream, available to purchase as scoops or in tubs to take home. No added sugar Braum’s ice cream flavor options include classics like vanilla and chocolate as well as treats like chocolate chip cookie dough.

The exact nutritional profile will vary based on the flavor, but each type has no added sugar and around 6 grams of naturally occurring sugars. A serving also has 4 grams of protein and 140 calories, making this added-sugar-free ice cream a balanced treat. 

3. Keto Pint Zero Added Sugar Ice Cream Bars

If you want sugar-free ice cream bars instead of a regular pint, this is a top pick. Keto Pint offers a few flavors of ice cream bar, including Vanilla Almond and Triple Chocolate Crunch. Some of these bars are also unique in that they contain 0 grams of total sugar. However, some flavors have a few grams of sugar or sugar alcohol. 

The sugar-free ice cream bars are also relatively low in calories at 140 calories per bar. Being a keto brand, it’s also not surprising that each ice cream bar has a relatively low amount of net carbs at around 2 to 3 grams per bar, plus 14 grams of fat per bar on average. 

4. So Delicious No Sugar Added Vanilla Bean Coconut Milk Frozen Dessert

For those seeking a dairy-free and sugar-free ice cream, So Delicious offers its Vanilla Bean Coconut Milk Frozen Dessert that hits the spot every single time. Made with a coconut milk base, this option provides a creamy texture and subtle tropical undertone that complements the classic vanilla flavor.

Sweetened with organic erythritol and monk fruit extract, So Delicious achieves a pleasant sweetness without any artificial aftertaste sometimes encountered with no-sugar-added ice cream. The addition of chicory root extract boosts the fiber content, contributing to a healthier dessert experience.

In every 2/3 cup serving, you can expect 2 grams of sugar with no added sugars, helping you meet the FDA guidelines of consuming no more than 50 grams of added sugar per day. While some may find the coconut flavor noticeable, many appreciate this as a unique twist on traditional vanilla ice cream.

5. Breyers No Sugar Added Vanilla

Breyers No Sugar Added Vanilla delivers a familiar taste and texture for those accustomed to traditional ice cream, while still being a low-sugar ice cream option. This almost sugar-free ice cream uses a blend of sucralose and acesulfame potassium to achieve its sweetness while keeping carbs low.

With its creamy texture and classic vanilla flavor, this versatile option can be enjoyed on its own, as a base for sundaes or with popular desserts like brownies. However, some consumers note that artificial sweeteners can be detected in the aftertaste. 

Each typical 150-gram serving contains 5 grams of sugar, none of which are added sugars. While not the lowest in sugar on this list or completely sugar-free, it’s a great added-sugar-free ice cream pick that’s lower in sugar than most options on the market while retaining a creamy and delicious taste. 

6. Edy's Slow Churned Light No Sugar Added Butter Pecan

Edy's Slow Churned Light No Sugar Added Butter Pecan provides a rich, nutty experience without the sugar overload. This added sugar-free ice cream uses sorbitol, maltodextrin and sucralose to achieve its sweetness, resulting in a flavor profile that closely mimics traditional butter pecan ice cream.

The creamy texture and generous inclusion of pecans make this a satisfying treat for those craving a classic ice cream experience. However, some consumers report mild digestive discomfort due to the sugar alcohols used.

A standard 2/3 cup serving contains 150 calories and 5 grams of sugar, with no added sugar. While it may be high in carbs, with 21 grams per serving, it does remain a reduced-sugar alternative to conventional ice cream that’s a top pick if you’re reducing sugar intake but are less concerned about carbs.

7. Skinny Cow No Sugar Added Vanilla Gone Wild! Ice Cream Sandwiches

For those who love the classic ice cream sandwich, Skinny Cow is here to offer a reduced sugar version with its No Sugar Added Vanilla Gone Wild! product. These individually wrapped treats feature creamy vanilla ice cream between two chocolate cookies, providing a satisfying combination of flavors and textures.

Sweetened with sucralose, these sugar-free ice cream sandwiches still achieve a pleasant sweetness. The portion-controlled format makes it easier to enjoy a treat without overindulging.

Each sandwich has 130 calories and contains 4 grams each of protein and sugar (none of which is added sugar). While higher in carbs than some ice cream pint options, with 27 grams of carbs per sandwich, the convenience and nostalgic appeal make these a popular choice among sugar-free ice cream enthusiasts.

8. Keto Pint Salted Caramel

Keto Pint's Salted Caramel flavor brings a decadent sugar-free ice cream experience for those following a ketogenic diet. This high-fat, low-carb option features a rich caramel base with a perfect balance of sweetness and saltiness.

With the added olive oil and sea salt, Keto Pint achieves the most indulgent flavor. The high cream content contributes to a luxuriously smooth texture that rivals traditional premium ice creams. 

A 2/3 cup serving contains only 2 grams of sugar, none of which is added sugar, and 14 grams of fat. While higher in calories due to its high-fat content at 170 calories per serving, this option is perfect for those prioritizing low sugar intake over calorie count.

If you don’t feel like salted caramel, other flavors with a similar nutritional profile include peanut butter, strawberry and vanilla bean. 

9. Nick's Swedish-Style Light Ice Cream Strawbär Swirl

Another popular pick from the brand Nick's, Strawbär Swirl takes a unique swirl on sugar-free ice cream. This option combines a creamy vanilla base with ribbons of strawberry sauce and chunks of strawberry, providing a fruity twist on the classic strawberries and cream.

Perfect for those following a keto-friendly diet, Nick's achieves a natural-tasting sweetness without added sugars. The use of milk protein contributes to a satisfying texture and boosts the protein content. 

Each 2/3 cup serving contains 1 gram of sugar and comes in at only 90 calories, making it one of the best low-calorie ice creams to try. Though fruit ice cream may not appeal to everyone and is different than most of the options on the list of sugar-free ice creams, the natural fruit content and creamy texture make it a popular choice. There’s also a mango and strawberry flavor to try, but this has 2 grams of natural sugar. 

10. Klondike No Sugar Added Krunch Bar

Klondike’s No Sugar Added Krunch Bar is another almost sugar-free ice cream treat that is just as good as the real thing. This crunchy bar features creamy vanilla ice cream with a crisp chocolatey shell dotted with bits of puffed rice, providing the perfect mix of flavors and textures.

Each bar contains 6 grams of sugar, none of which is added sugar, and only 160 calories. The innovative flavor combination, brand nostalgia and no-sugar-added profile make this a standout option in the sugar-free ice cream market.

11. Halo Top Keto Series Pops

Halo Top's Keto Series offers delightful low-sugar ice cream pops in a few flavors for a decadent taste experience without the sugar overload. Ranking as one of the most popular picks on lists of the best no-sugar-added ice cream choices, these ice cream bars are keto-friendly and contain only 2 to 4 grams of sugar, none of which is added.

Each low-sugar ice cream pop also has only 2 to 3 grams of net carbs and 3 grams of protein, with calories ranging from 290 to 390. Flavors to enjoy include peanut butter, salted caramel and chocolate cheesecake. All varieties feature delicious ice cream with flavor swirls in a crisp chocolate shell.  

12. Outshine No Sugar Added Frozen Fruit Pops

Okay, so this isn’t ice cream, but if you’re looking for no-added-sugar desserts, these fruit popsicles are a top choice, offering all the refreshing and flavorful qualities of ice cream.

Featuring delicious strawberry, raspberry and tangerine flavors, these added sugar-free ice creams are made with real fruit juice, have only 1 gram of naturally occurring sugar and are a good source of vitamin C. They're fat-free as well, a bonus if you’re cutting back on fats as well as sugar.

Outshine No Sugar Added Frozen Fruit Pops are also an excellent healthy snack for kids if you’re looking for an alternative to more unhealthy types of ice creams or fruit pops. 

What Is the Best Low-Sugar Ice Cream?

Determining the best sugar-free ice cream ultimately comes down to personal preference and dietary needs. Some individuals may prioritize the lowest possible sugar content, while others might focus on overall carb count or prefer dairy-free options. Flavor preferences also play a significant role in choosing the best no-sugar ice cream.

For those seeking the absolute lowest sugar content, options like Rebel Creamery and Keto Pint offer flavors with 1 gram or less of sugar per serving. These brands also tend to have the lowest net carb counts, making them suitable for strict ketogenic diets. However, they are often higher in calories due to a high fat content.

Individuals looking for a balance between low sugar and lower calories might prefer a brand like Skinny Cow, which offers treats like ice cream sandwiches with only 130 calories and 4 grams of sugar. For those with dairy allergies or following a plant-based diet, brands like So Delicious offer plant-based, added-sugar-free ice creams.

Homemade Low-Sugar Ice Cream

It's worth noting that making your own ice cream using homemade ice cream recipes is also an excellent option for controlling sugar content. Recipes using naturally sweet ingredients like ripe bananas or berries can create delicious frozen treats with minimal to no added sugars and low to zero total sugars.

This approach allows for complete control over ingredients and sweetness levels and allows for the chance to create unique sugar-free ice cream flavors at home. Great choices include high-protein cottage cheese ice cream that's sweetened with natural honey or maple syrup and rainbow popsicles with only fruit and healthy Greek yogurt as ingredients.

Is Sugar-Free Ice Cream Low Carb?

While the best no-sugar ice cream often has fewer carbs than traditional ice cream, it's not always strictly low-carb. The carb content can vary significantly between brands and flavors.

Many sugar-free ice creams use sugar alcohols or other low-calorie sweeteners to achieve sweetness without adding sugar. While these sweeteners don't contribute to the sugar content, they may still add to the total carb count. However, some brands, particularly those marketed as keto-friendly, focus on keeping both sugar and total carbs low.

For example, sugar-free ice cream brands like Rebel Creamery and Keto Pint typically have very low net carb counts (often 2 to 3 grams per serving), making them suitable for low-carb and ketogenic diets.

On the other hand, some sugar-free ice creams may have 10 grams or more of net carbs per serving, which might not fit into stricter low-carb eating plans. It's essential to read nutrition labels carefully and consider net carbs when evaluating whether a sugar-free ice cream fits into a low-carb diet and qualifies as the healthiest ice cream for your needs.

No added sugar and sugar-free ice creams have come a long way in recent years, offering a wide range of flavors and textures to suit various dietary needs and preferences. From creamy, indulgent options perfect for keto dieters to lighter, fruit-based treats for those watching calories, there's likely a sugar-free ice cream to satisfy every craving.

As you may have discovered with this list, it’s challenging to find a completely sugar-free ice cream on the market. However, there are many options with zero added sugars and a minimal amount of total sugars.

With this guide to low-sugar ice cream in hand, you can now confidently find a treat in the ice cream aisle, knowing that your sugar intake for the day won’t be negatively affected in the way it would with standard ice cream. 

For even more ways to explore your favorite foods, check out other experiences happening on Cozymeal.