13 Best Jersey Mike's Secret Menu Items To Try in 2025

The Jersey Mike’s secret menu is no longer a well-kept secret. It offers new ways to tempt your tastebuds and feed your appetite, comprised of staff-concocted varieties and fan-favorite specialty subs, both hot and cold.

Curious about which sandwiches reign supreme on Jersey Mike’s secret menu? Wondering how to place an order or even add your signature creation to the list of fan favorites? Let’s dive in and uncover the delicious secrets that await.

 Jump to Section

• Does Jerseys Mike's Have a Secret Menu?
• Jersey Mike's Secret Menu Cold Subs
• Jersey Mike's Secret Menu Hot Subs
• Jersey Mike's Secret Menu Salads and Vegetarian

Does Jerseys Mike's Have a Secret Menu?

Jersey Mike's doesn't formally advertise a secret menu, but most locations are flexible with customizations or offer off-menu items upon request. While there's no standardized Jersey Mike’s secret menu, creative customers and accommodating staff sometimes create unique combinations that differ from the regular menu. 

How does a sub find its way onto the secret menu? By adding or removing an ingredient from a Jersey Mike’s sub or combining meats and vegetables in new ways, guests create secret menu items that the chain’s most loyal visitors covet. 

Jersey Mike's Secret Menu Cold Subs

1. Surf 'n' Turf

Does roast beef and tuna sound like an odd combination, or does it intrigue you? The unique pairing of meat from the sea and meat from the land makes it a standout selection on Jersey Mike’s secret menu. 

To order this Jersey Mike’s secret menu item, simply request the Club Supreme as your base. Then, swap out the turkey for tuna, add Swiss cheese and omit the bacon. The flavor is hearty and salty, with a touch of smokiness from the roast beef. Add your favorite vegetables to create a complete and satisfying meal. 

2. The Martian

Craving a flavor-packed surprise? Picture this: the bold fusion of salami and pepperoni in one mouthwatering Jersey Mike’s secret menu sandwich. Unconventional yet undeniably delicious, this culinary creation is sure to tantalize your tastebuds and leave you craving more.

To sample this taste adventure, order a #5 (The Super Sub) and swap out the ham for savory salami, trade the prosciutto for zesty pepperoni and add provolone. The mildness of the cheese perfectly balances the spiciness of the meats. 

3. Cuban Supreme

Transport yourself to Havana with this tantalizing Jersey Mike’s secret menu sub. Packed with tender proscuittini, salted cappacuolo, succulent ham, Swiss cheese, zesty pickles and spicy mustard, it's a taste sensation not to be missed. 

Just request a #5 and customize it to perfection. Substitute provolone with Swiss cheese, swap salami for cappacuolo and top it off with pickles and spicy mustard."

4. Turkey Bacon Ranch Sub

Enjoy the classic turkey sub with a hint of salty bacon, fresh crisped vegetables and creamy ranch dressing. This Jersey Mike’s secret menu item takes the traditional turkey sandwich and turns it up a notch! 

To enjoy this flavor-packed sub, start with a soft, freshly baked sub roll. Then add tender slices of deli-sliced turkey breast, smoked bacon strips, crisp lettuce and juicy tomatoes. Finish with a healthy dose of creamy ranch dressing. 

Jersey Mike's Secret Menu Hot Subs

5. Big Kahuna Cheese Steak with Chipotle Mayo

This sub is a great choice for anyone who enjoys a classic cheesesteak sandwich but on the spicy side. Also known as #99, this creation includes tender grilled steak, aromatic onions, mushrooms, peppers and melted cheese. What sets it apart is the fiery kick from jalapeños and the creamy richness of chipotle mayo.

To savor this hidden gem from Jersey Mike’s secret menu, request the Big Kahuna Cheese Steak with Chipotle Mayo by name. Alternatively, you can order a #56 combined with a #43 from the regular menu.

6. The Chicka-Fila-Roni

Give this sandwich a try if you want to experience a twist on the classic Philly cheesesteak. This flavorful sandwich swaps out traditional steak for grilled chicken and adds a kick of spicy pepperoni. Packed with bold flavors, it's guaranteed to satisfy your appetite in a whole new way.

To order this Jersey Mike’s secret menu item, ask for a Mike’s Famous Philly but request the sandwich artist to replace the steak with chicken and add a healthy dose of pepperoni. 

7. Pepperoni Pizza Sub

How do succulent pepperoni slices and gooey melted cheese nestled between two soft buns sound? This is the Jersey Mike’s secret menu item to choose from when you yearn for pizza, but the rest of the family wants subs. This hidden delight includes all the deliciousness of a slice of pizza and promises to be a delight.

To savor this hidden delight begin with a #3 (Ham and Provolone). Then, request red sauce on the bottom slice of bread, swap Swiss for provolone and replace ham with pepperoni. Tell your sandwich artist to heat it to experience all the pizza-like deliciousness.

8. Cafeteria Classic

Sink your teeth into a warm, toasted bun filled with savory ham slices and melted Swiss cheese. The rich flavors mingle harmoniously in each bite of this Jersey Mike’s secret menu classic, creating a comforting sensation that envelops your palate. 

Give this one a try by requesting a #3. Substitute Swiss cheese for the provolone and heat it. Finally, add a bit of mustard. Your tastebuds will thank you!  

9. Buffalo Chicken Sub

This Jersey Mike's secret menu sub is a fiery delight for those craving a spicy kick. Tender pieces of grilled or breaded chicken breast are tossed in zesty buffalo sauce, infusing every bite with a bold and tangy flavor. Crisp lettuce and juicy tomatoes add a refreshing contrast to the heat, while blue cheese dressing or crumbles provide a creamy and cooling element. 

Ask for a chicken sub tossed in buffalo sauce, then customize it with your preferred choice of cheese, veggies and condiments. Heat the sandwich to bring out the authentic Buffalo chicken flavor. 

Jersey Mike's Secret Menu Salads and Vegetarian

10. Sub in a Tub

This Jersey Mike’s secret menu hack lets you take your favorite sub and transform it into a salad, ideal for anyone who's watching carbs or following a keto-type diet. The "sub in a tub" option allows you to enjoy any item from the menu sans bread, ideal for a low-carb or carb-free alternative.

To order this item, simply choose your favorite menu item and request it in a tub. From there, personalize your tub with your choice of meats, cheese, vegetables, condiments or dressings. 

11. Sweet Pepper Wrap

The ideal choice for Jersey Mike’s fans seeking a flavorful yet calorie-conscious option. This healthy secret menu wrap combines the best qualities of a soft spinach wrap with the bold flavors of grilled bell peppers, banana peppers and sweet onions. A dose of chipotle mayonnaise adds smokey notes. 

Enjoy this wrap by requesting a grilled veggie wrap with a substitution of cherry pepper relish and chipotle mayonnaise for the ranch. Then, add grilled bell peppers and your favorite cheese to finish things off. 

12. Lumberjack Salad

For a protein-packed lunch that is also filled with flavor, try the Jersey Mike’s secret menu lumberjack salad. This hearty and flavorful salad includes black pepper ham, fresh roast beef, plenty of vegetables, applewood smoked bacon and sharp Swiss cheese. 

Start with a #9 in a tub. Then, add your choice of steak or chicken, along with a selection of fresh vegetables. Substitute proscuittini for turkey and add plenty of spicy mustard plus your favorite dressing, if desired. 

13. Avocado Veggie Sub

Enjoy the health benefits of creamy, fresh avocado and various garden-fresh vegetables in this satisfying and flavorful Jersey Mike’s secret menu vegetarian sub. This one is a cool, refreshing and healthy choice to enjoy during summer’s hottest months.

This sandwich is one you will need to order from scratch. Start with your favorite bread and ask your sandwich artist to add several slices of fresh avocado. Then, choose your other fresh vegetables. Lettuce, tomato, onion and cucumber are all good options. Finish with a bit of mayonnaise, oil and vinegar and salt and pepper. 

When you want a change from their regular menu, Jersey Mike’s secret menu has some great options. Each sub or salad is packed with flavor, loaded with your favorite meats and vegetables and a great way to switch up your lunchtime routine. Give one a try today!

For even more ways to explore your favorite foods, check out other experiences happening on Cozymeal.