23 Best Breyers Ice Cream Flavors To Try in 2025
Would you have guessed that some of the Breyers ice cream flavors you see every time you visit your grocery store have delighted customers since 1866? What began with William A. Breyer hand-churning his first gallon in Philadelphia is now one of the country's most recognizable and loved ice cream brands.
Using only ingredients of the highest quality, the renowned brand has built up a reputation for classic and indulgent flavors that are now also available in dietary-conscious alternatives. The sheer variety of Breyers ice cream flavors available can be confusing, and knowing which ones to stock up on can be tricky. That’s why we’ve rounded up and ranked the 23 best Breyers ice cream flavors to help you discover your new all-time favorites.
Jump to Section
How Many Flavors of Ice Cream Does Breyers Have?
If this question has ever crossed your mind, the answer is…more than you think! Breyers ice cream flavors cater to almost every palate and preference. The company has been associated with premium ice cream for over 150 years, and it prides itself on always offering its customers something new to try out and enjoy. The exact number of flavors will always fluctuate based on changes, but there's always enough to go around.
From classic flavors like Natural Vanilla, Chocolate, and Cookies and Cream to innovative combinations such as Pistachio Almond and Cherry Vanilla, there’s something for everyone. The Breyers ice cream flavors list gets even more exotic with the Cookies and Candies line that introduces popular candies like Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups, Snickers and Oreos as delicious mix-ins.
If you want something lighter and more calorie-conscious, the CarbSmart range offers reduced-carb ice cream bars that allow you to enjoy a guilt-free sweet treat. The Breyers Delights line also features lower-calorie choices without compromising on taste or texture.
Looking to skip dairy altogether? No problem! Dairy-free Breyers ice cream flavors are made with oat milk and feature classic offerings with a twist, such as Non-Dairy Vanilla, Non-Dairy Chocolate, and Non-Dairy Cookies and Crème.
While the company is known for its commitment to quality and transparency, the brand recently made headlines for a different reason. As part of a class-action settlement (where all claims were denied), Breyers agreed to an eight million+ U.S. dollar payout related to mislabeling claims.
Today, Breyers ice cream flavors are made from the best high-quality ingredients sourced from American farmers. The milk and cream used are devoid of artificial growth hormones, ensuring ethical and sustainable products.
What Flavors of Breyers Ice Cream Are Gluten-Free?
The good news is that many Breyers ice cream flavors are gluten-free. The bad news is that not all of them are, so you need to check the labels before consuming them without any worry. Breyers marks each gluten-free product with an easily identifiable green seal on the packaging. The gluten-free Breyers ice cream flavors are vast and varied.
Classics such as Chocolate, Mint Chocolate Chip and Dulce de Leche are popular choices, as are their innovative CarbSmart Vanilla and Fudge bars. The Non-Dairy Vanilla flavor is both gluten-free and vegan, offering a double whammy of goodness to those with sensitivities and dietary restrictions.
However, when it comes to the special cups of Breyers ice cream flavors, things get a little tricky. A glance at the labels doesn’t indicate any gluten, but it’s highly possible that the products are not labeled gluten-free as they might be produced in a facility where cross-contamination is possible. Unfortunately, Breyers does not make ice cream cakes for their celiac-sensitive customers either.
The company does, however, take gluten safety and intolerance very seriously and ensures that protocols like allergen training and ingredient segregation are always maintained. Nonetheless, it is still recommended that you check the packaging for the most accurate information. The website isn’t always up-to-date, and manufacturing processes can change.
Breyers Ice Cream Flavors List: 23 Top Picks
1. Natural Vanilla
Everyone needs a classic vanilla ice cream they turn to in times of need. Whether it’s an add-on for a pie or on its own, an ideal vanilla ice cream should be creamy but light, not too sweet but not too bland either and have visible vanilla bean flecks. Natural Vanilla is one of those classic Breyers ice cream flavors that is uncomplicated and pleasant.
Now, if you are looking for something a bit more indulgent or exciting, this may not be the right choice. What it lacks in terms of richness (as compared to other high-end brands), it makes up for in lighter calorie and fat content. Overall, this is a great choice for a comforting ice cream experience. Nothing more. Nothing less.
2. Natural Strawberry
Remember those Nesquik strawberry milk drinks you couldn't get enough of as a kid (or as an adult)? Well, the Natural Strawberry Breyers ice cream flavor hits exactly the same notes. Fruity, sweet and lusciously creamy, it's a refreshing taste on a classic. The addition of real strawberry pieces takes the creamy concoction to the next level with tangy chewy bites that melt in the mouth.
However, for some, the texture does not meet the mark. Keep in mind, though, that strawberry ice cream comes with a particular set of expectations. Some people prefer a pink, strawberry dessert that is refreshing and zesty, while others welcome the ‘real’ version of vanilla ice cream with puddles of fruit chunks. This Breyers ice cream flavor falls in the latter camp, which means you either love it or hate it — no in-between.
3. Non-Dairy Cookies and Crème
This inventive product will undoubtedly catch the eyes of those with dairy sensitivities or plant-based enthusiasts. The Non-Dairy range of products is the perfect choice if you love your sweet treats but have to be more careful with the ingredients used, and this one doesn't disappoint. Smooth vanilla ice cream combines with crunchy crème-filled cookie pieces for a delightful duo that may have your dairy-eating friends questioning their choices.
However, caution must be taken as some of the products may have come in contact with other allergens like soy, peanuts or eggs. Breyers ice cream flavors from the Non-Dairy line usually run out very fast, so move quickly to avoid disappointment.
4. CarbSmart Brownie a la Mode
Out of all the Breyers ice cream flavors ranked, the CarbSmart range has people on the fence. Some swear by it, claiming to finally love a dessert that is “good” for them, while others prefer to stay away. That said, if you are diabetic or on a low-carb diet, this product range is right up your alley.
The Brownie a la Mode frozen dessert ranks in at just five grams of net carbs and 120 calories per serving. It offers a sweet little treat to satisfy those cravings while fitting into your dietary requirements. The vanilla base of this Breyer ice cream flavor is packed with chunks of brownie dough, and a rich fudge swirl is worked through, making each mouthful a delicious balance of flavors and textures.
5. Cherry Vanilla
For a delightful blend of creamy vanilla ice cream studded with real cherries, this Breyers ice cream flavor is the one for you. The sweet and tart cherry chunks contrast beautifully with the smooth vanilla base, making it a real crowd-pleaser by not being too fruity or too rich. Enjoy this versatile flavor on its own or as a complement to other desserts.
Breyers ice cream flavors, like Cherry Vanilla, also highlight the brand’s dedication to ethical sourcing. The cherries are 100% sustainably farmed, and the vanilla is sourced from Rainforest Alliance-certified farms in Madagascar.
6. Double Cookie Crumble
The Double Cookie Crumble takes everyone's favorite cookie ice cream and amps it up a level. We are talking double the amount of Oreo cookie chunks plus an added swirl of chocolate cookies, ensuring each bite of this Breyers ice cream flavor is packed with crunch and deliciousness.
Like all other Breyers ice cream flavors, this one is also committed to using only the best quality ingredients and colors from natural sources. If you are considering various popular desserts to serve to a crowd, look no further than the Double Cookie Crumble, which is often available at a discount during store sales.
7. Vanilla Chocolate Strawberry
Also known as Neapolitan, this Breyers ice cream flavor is a nostalgic classic. Offering three favorite flavors — vanilla, strawberry and chocolate — in one delicious tub, reviewers appreciate the homemade taste and smooth texture. Each flavor holds its own, with the sweetness of the vanilla complementing the rich fudginess of the chocolate.
In turn, the strawberry section offers a refreshing fruity lightness with real strawberry pieces. One of the best parts about this Breyers ice cream flavor is that with the separate layers, you can enjoy each taste individually or together in one delightful spoonful, depending on your mood.
8. Vanilla Chocolate
When Breyers Natural Vanilla and Chocolate ice creams come together in one tub, you know you are in for a treat. Ice cream lovers need not choose between two classic favorites, but can instead enjoy the best of both worlds in one convenient package.
The vanilla is crafted with real Madagascar vanilla beans for the most authentic vanilla taste. Meanwhile, the chocolate, with its rich cocoa taste, perfectly complements the vanilla and completes a delightfully simple Breyers ice cream flavor that's perfect for any occasion.
9. Dulce de Leche
Another fan favorite, this Breyers ice cream flavor is a must for caramel lovers. While it might be classified as a frozen dairy dessert, it is still made with Grade A milk and cream that results in a rich, velvety vanilla base with ribbons of caramel swirl running through.
This creates a bold yet balanced treat where the sweetness of the caramel is modulated by the neutral, velvety nature of the vanilla ice cream. It has received praise for the complexity and sophistication of its flavor profile, though some customers have not appreciated its relabeling from ice cream to a frozen dessert.
10. Coffee
Coffee is one of those Breyers ice cream flavors that appeals to people who prefer their treats on the sweeter side. With a smooth energizing taste, thanks to the 100% Colombian coffee used to make it, the dessert is also nutritionally light, containing just 140 calories per serving.
However, long-time customers have reported disappointment over the new improvements to the classic recipe. Now labeled a frozen dessert due to the presence of stabilizers and emulsifiers, some people have not appreciated the resulting change in texture and consistency. But, while it may not be a premium ice cream experience, it still hits the spot with its subtle caffeine kick and lighter sweet taste.
11. CarbSmart Vanilla and Almond Bars
The CarbSmart Vanilla and Almond bars deliver both flavor and nutrition with just 5 grams of net carbs and 150 calories per serving. As Breyers ice cream flavors go, these creamy, crunchy treats prove that fewer carbs do not mean sacrificing taste. Each bar consists of a creamy vanilla center covered by a crispy chocolate shell studded with almond pieces.
Customers can’t stop raving about the CarbSmart Breyers ice cream flavors and find them a delicious option that fits easily into a low-carb lifestyle. They are also suitable for diabetics who crave something sweet without the dangerous sugar overload.
12. Rocky Road
Among the many Breyers ice cream flavors, the Rocky Road recipe has been tweaked a couple of times — but not to everyone’s satisfaction. While the smooth chocolate ice cream base is still rich and creamy, the brand has brought back the chocolate-covered almonds mixed in. This, according to loyal fans, has made the balance of sweet, crunchy and chewy feel off.
According to the latest reviews, the overwhelming crunch of the almonds masks the sweetness of the marshmallows and chocolate. However, before reverting back to the original recipe, people complained about the absence of the almonds. As the saying goes, "You can't please everyone." While the updated recipe may not be for everyone, it still delivers a decadent experience you may enjoy after trying it for yourself.
13. Reese’s Chocolate
For fans of chocolate and peanut butter (and let’s be honest, who isn’t?), Reese’s Chocolate frozen delight from the range of Breyers ice cream flavors is something you don’t want to miss out on. Real Reese’s peanut butter cups are added to this gloriously sweet and salty ice cream, and each spoonful delivers a blend of smooth chocolate and crunchy, salty peanut butter chunks.
Customers insist that this innovative Breyers ice cream flavor is even better than the original Reese’s Peanut Butter ice cream, but despite its popularity, many find it hard to locate. So, if you get your hands on this candy-inspired dessert, remember to stock up, or you may not find another batch before your next craving hits.
14. Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
A familiar favorite among Breyers ice cream flavors, the Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough ice cream ticks all the good dessert boxes. It features creamy vanilla, chocolate chunks and fudgy cookie dough pieces. Every spoonful offers a balance of creaminess, crunch and delectable chocolate.
While customers appreciate the ratio of cookie dough to ice cream base, some reviews do complain that the dough pieces are not as soft and chewy as expected. However, this Breyers ice cream flavor remains a nostalgic and comforting treat for dessert lovers. To top it off, each serving contains only 190 calories, making it an indulgence worth enjoying.
15. Chocolate
No true chocolate lover would be without this Breyers ice cream flavor in their freezers. Made with fresh cream and real cocoa, it offers just the right amount of sweetness and decadence.
Fans rave about its simple ingredient list because, like other Breyers ice cream flavors, it is a dessert you can feel good about sharing with your family. While some customers wish it were discounted more often, its unbeatable taste and creamy texture keep it on everyone’s shopping lists throughout the year.
16. CarbSmart Mint Fudge Cookie
The Mint Fudge Cookie frozen dairy dessert is a refreshing treat that is also low in carbs, which is excellent news for those keeping track of their macros and looking to eat healthier. With its cool mint flavor, rich fudge swirls and satisfying cookie pieces, it has none of the artificial aftertaste usually associated with diet-friendly desserts.
Fans of the brand love how the CarbSmart Mint Fudge Cookie treat captures the creamy, full-bodied taste of traditional ice cream, making it a staple in many freezers. While some customers find this Breyers ice cream flavor challenging to locate in stores, its delicious taste and guilt-free nutrition content make it worth the search.
17. Reese’s Peanut Butter
America’s favorite chocolate and peanut butter candy just got even better with this Breyers ice cream flavor. Think creamy, smooth peanut butter ice cream with big chunks of Reese’s Cups, and you have the perfect combination of sweet and salty that customers can’t get enough of.
Fans of Reese’s Peanut Butter rave about this rich and indulgent Breyers ice cream flavor, and like its counterpart on this list, some even prefer it over the original candy. While some wish for a slightly lower sugar content, the overall experience keeps it a must-have in freezers everywhere.
18. Butter Pecan
Indulge in the irresistible combination of rich vanilla and buttery roasted pecans with this delectable Breyers ice cream flavor. The pecans are carefully roasted in butter, enhancing their natural flavor before being swirled into the vanilla ice cream base.
Each bite of this standout Breyers ice cream flavor delivers a delightful mix of textures, with the buttery, nutty flavor complementing the sweet, smooth ice cream. While some may wish for even more pecans, the overall taste makes this a top pick for many customers who prefer their ice cream with a bit of crunch.
19. Star Spangled Scoops
Bring out your patriotic spirit with this unique Breyers ice cream flavor. Star Spangled Scoops is a special edition dessert that brings together three classic flavors of vanilla, strawberry and blueberry.
This red, white and blue treat is the perfect summer dessert, whether enjoyed on its own or as a topping for fresh fruit and pies. Fans especially love the blueberry flavor, and many hope to find an entire tub dedicated to this delicious new addition to the permanent lineup of Breyers ice cream flavors.
20. New York Style Cheesecake (Strawberry)
Attention, cheesecake lovers — there’s a new Breyers ice cream flavor in town that’s going to be your go-to snack. This popular product blends creamy cheesecake-flavored ice cream with a zesty strawberry sauce and chunks of graham-covered cheesecake pieces. It’s like enjoying two treats in one, according to customer reviews, and is so delicious that one serving is rarely enough.
21. Snickers
A part of their Cookies and Candies range, the Snickers Breyers ice cream flavor is perfect as a special treat when needed (or wanted). Customers compare it to their favorite comfort snack as it captures the essence of a classic Snickers candy bar without being overly sweet.
The caramel ribbons and chocolate-coated peanuts, along with real Snickers bar pieces, are mixed into the classic vanilla ice cream to create a new favorite Breyers ice cream flavor that is sure to satisfy.
22. S’Mores (Campfire Collection)
For a delicious trip down memory lane, look no further than the S’Mores collection of Breyers ice cream flavors. This innovative treat features marshmallow-flavored frozen dairy dessert swirled through with milk chocolate (yes, Hershey’s) and crunchy graham crackers. Fans can’t stop talking about how this new addition to the list of Breyers ice cream flavors perfectly captures the essence of a freshly toasted s’more.
Also available are the Campfire Collection S’mores ice cream sandwiches and bars for more on-the-go Breyers ice cream flavor options. The only drawback is the possibility that Breyers may make this a seasonal flavor and stop producing this indulgent treat in a few months.
23. Pistachio Almond
When it comes to Breyers ice cream flavors ranked according to popularity, there’s a particular dream combination that consistently receives high praise. The Pistachio Almond Breyers ice cream flavor mixes fresh cream, roasted almonds and rich pistachio in an irresistible fusion of taste and texture. It's considered one of those rare pistachio ice creams that get the balance of quality and flavor just right.
Breyers Ice Cream flavors offer the best variety of options to appeal to any dessert lover. However, it’s important to keep in mind any personal dietary needs before indulging. If you have any sensitivities to dairy, gluten or any other specific health conditions, ensure you review the ingredient list carefully.
Whether you’re craving a simple scoop or something more decadent, Breyers has a flavor for every occasion. With their commitment to high-quality ingredients, each flavor is crafted to deliver a rich and satisfying experience. The 23 best Breyers ice cream flavors showcase the brand's dedication to quality and innovation, making it a go-to choice for dessert lovers everywhere.
For even more ways to explore your favorite foods, check out other experiences happening on Cozymeal.
FOOD FOR THOUGHT?
Join the conversation.