Blue Bell Ice Cream Flavors List: 21 Best Picks Ranked for 2025
There may be no collection of sweet treats that merges nostalgia and novelty better than Blue Bell ice cream flavors. From the quaint cow and dairy girl silhouette logo to the thoughtful mix-ins and flavor combinations, the company goes to great lengths to ensure an old-fashioned dessert experience.
But that doesn't mean Blue Bell ice cream flavors aren't keeping up with modern consumers; by cranking out a slew of updated inventions, the ever-evolving Blue Bell ice cream flavors list keeps customers coming back for more. Given that 97% of Americans love or like ice cream, according to a survey by the International Dairy Foods Association, it's no surprise that Blue Bell continues to innovate while maintaining its nostalgic charm.
With so many flavors taking up real estate in the freezer case, which Blue Bell ice cream flavors are your top picks for a tempting treat, and which ones are you better off leaving in the cold? This gathering of 21 Blue Bell ice cream flavors ranked by deliciousness gets to the icy heart of the matter by ranking the cartons to help you make a more informed decision. Brace yourself for a sweet summary of the best Blue Bell has to offer!
Jump to Section
21 Best Blue Bell Ice Cream Flavors
1. Mint Chocolate Chip
How could any connoisseur of classic ice cream not rate into chocolate chip among the best Blue Bell ice cream flavors ever? The frosty freshness of cool mint ice cream with generous handfuls of chocolate chips scattered throughout presents the perfect combination of rich and sweet without going overboard. It’s a scoop shop standard that fits perfectly in your home ice cream collection, though it may not last long enough to take up permanent residence.
2. Pecan Pralines ‘n Cream
The Southern charm of caramel-like praline sauce and candy-coated pecans nestled in vanilla ice cream gives Pecan Pralines ‘n Cream high ranking among all Blue Bell ice cream combinations. This mindful blend represents a fun Louisiana treat that piles on the sugary goodness in a way that shows off regional spirit without being brash or showy. It’s a major step up from the usual pecan-studded ice cream and a supreme treat for anyone who loves a more homemade style of caramel-style treats.
3. Tin Roof
When you have chocolate fudge sauce ribbons and real roasted peanuts coated in dark chocolate scattered throughout a bucket of vanilla ice cream, you have one of the most enjoyable Blue Bell ice cream flavors on the market. Tin Roof brings back old-time innocence by using simple flavors that always work splendidly together. This is one for ice cream lovers with peanut sensitivities to watch out for.
4. Coffee
Natural coffee beans infuse this earthy Blue Bell ice cream creation with a warm coffee-shop essence. The finished product is meant to taste like your favorite java with just the right amount of cream splashed in for good measure. You could return the favor by dropping a scoop into your coffee mug in the morning in place of creamer, just to see what happens.
5. Java Jolt
Double up your delight with a pint of Java Jolt and experience one of the more inspired Blue Bell ice cream treats in the portfolio. This carton takes Blue Bell’s Coffee ice cream and decorates it with dark chocolate chunks to make things more delicious. It's a two-fisted fun fest of coffee and chocolate essences that wake up your taste buds like nobody’s business. Who needs Starbucks when you have Blue Bell ice cream flavors like this waiting in the freezer to wake up your taste buds?
6. Banana Pudding
Vanilla wafer cookies and whipped topping get in on the fun of becoming Blue Bell ice cream flavors amidst a banana ice cream base that performs a perfect impression of homemade banana pudding, one of the most popular desserts and a staple of home dining all over the U.S. Who needs to layer all of those pieces in together when Blue Bell puts them all into the carton for you in perfect balance?
7. Oatmeal Cream Pie
Incorporating elements of a classic snack cake into a carton of sweet, soothing bliss introduced Oatmeal Cream Pie into the suite of Blue Bell ice cream flavors as a celebration of National Ice Cream Month in 2022. By mixing oatmeal ice cream with brown sugar and pieces of real oatmeal cookie, the company offers a homestyle flavor fusion that feels familiar yet fresh. Sticking with tried and true tastes is a hallmark of how Blue Bell ice cream flavors work best, even when the company stretches its imagination for a fun taste-twister like this.
8. Pistachio Almond
Things get a little nutty with Pistachio Almond, one of the more perplexing Blue Bell ice cream flavors, though that doesn’t necessarily make it less delicious. Roasted almonds are strewn throughout a creamy green pistachio ice cream, which may be a taste mix, but it makes you wonder why there aren’t pistachios present instead. Blue Bell surely has its reasons, no matter how mysterious they might be.
9. Cookies ‘n Cream
Maybe you aren’t aware that the now-standard cookies and cream started its existence as one of the most inventive Blue Bell ice cream flavors. By working chunks of cream-filled chocolate cookies into its already fantastic vanilla ice cream, the company came up with one of the most enduring twists on ice cream culture. It may be an option that overtakes the ice cream aisle with imitators and emulators, but when you dip your spoon into first-in-class Blue Bell ice cream flavors like this, you’re experiencing a true original.
10. Cookie Two Step
By blending two popular Blue Bell ice cream flavors into a mega-mix of tastes and textures, Cookie Two Step invites fans of both cookies and cream and cookie dough ice cream to enjoy their beloved Blue Bell ice cream flavors in a single concoction. It’s also an easy way to avoid spending twice as much on your frozen desserts, though with this much delicious possibility under the lid you might have to buy two cartons just to stay satisfied.
11. Strawberry Toaster Pastry
If you’ve ever had the idea of smashing pop tarts into your ice cream, Strawberry Toaster Pastry is the option that does the smashing for you. This is one of the best Blue Bell ice cream flavors for combining fruity flavors with chunky textures and rich, creamy ice cream to make a magnificent mashup of a dessert dish that doesn’t require a cone, thanks to the crust-like pastry pieces embedded throughout. This flavor only makes appearances in smaller pint-sized cartons, maybe because it’s too powerful to exist in greater quantities.
12. Cherry Vanilla
The refreshingly simple combination of flavors in Cherry Vanilla creates one of those special Blue Bell ice cream flavors that call to mind the neighborhood ice cream truck or a trip to the soda shop for a sweet treat. There’s something supremely pure about the unadorned pairing of vanilla and cherries that makes it irresistible. Even if those experiences seem like far-off memories, this smooth vanilla ice cream peppered with real maraschino cherry pieces is nostalgic enough to recreate long-ago moments for a whole new generation.
13. Butter Crunch
You may find the crispy peanut butter and chocolate candy chunks that populate Butter Crunch suspiciously familiar. This is one of those sneaky Blue Bell ice cream flavors that uses popular candy bar inspiration similar to Butterfinger to conjure up an ice cream that feels like a home invention you’ve been making yourself for years. You can almost picture the Blue Bell workers cutting in the candy, à la Cold Stone Creamery.
14. Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
This company couldn’t call itself a forward-thinking ice cream creator without having chocolate chip cookie dough in its catalog. Capturing the fun mix-up of edible cookie dough and old-fashioned ice cream, this Blue Bell ice cream flavor goes all-in on the cookie dough madness by scattering its ice cream through and through with tiny spheres of chocolate chip-studded dough. Dark chocolate chips finish out the profile to make the tastes and textures more complex.
15. Ultimate Neapolitan
What roundup of Blue Bell ice cream flavors without the inclusion of ultimate Neapolitan? This traditional mix of vanilla, chocolate and strawberry may not be the flashiest, but it’s one that never lets you down. Whether you grab them all at once, separate them after they’re in your bowl or scoop out only your favorite and leave the others in the carton, having three classics to choose from is an ice cream diehard’s dream come true.
16. Dr. Pepper Float
Indulge your appetite for soda shop-style combinations with Dr. Pepper float, one of the more unique Blue Bell ice cream flavors to incorporate brand partnerships. This twisted twirl spins together Dr. Pepper sherbet with vanilla ice cream to capture the essence of an old-time malt shop no matter where you enjoy your scoop. The result is a creamy cousin of the root beer float, with just enough modern magic to find its own place in the line-up.
17. A&W Root Beer Float
It may not get sudsy like the original creation, but with A&W Root Beer Float drifting among the frosty sea of Blue Bell ice cream flavors, lovers of the malt shop classic can enjoy the refreshing flavors without having to gather the ingredients. The combination of slushy A&W sherbet with soothing vanilla ice cream captures the spirit of a real float in a handy carton that makes it simple to scoop and enjoy. It’s a fun way to introduce younger ice cream eaters to a timeless blend that doesn’t always get its due in the modern dessert world.
18. Strawberries and Homemade Vanilla
Down home delights don’t get simpler than Strawberries and Homemade Vanilla ice cream, one of the few Blue Bell ice cream flavors to incorporate real fruit. Juicy strawberries stand in stark contrast to the creamy vanilla base here, recreating a handcrafted ice cream that never goes out of style. It’s like sinking your spoon into a frozen version of strawberry shortcake minus the cake, though nothing is stopping you from adding a scoop to a slice of sponge cake or pound cake to fill in the missing pieces.
19. Gooey Butter Cake
Cake butter ice cream run through with a swirl of cream cheese frosting and pieces of real St. Louis-style butter cake? If Gooey Butter Cake isn’t one of the go-to Blue Bell ice cream flavors for ice cream lovers who live to swirl their cake and ice cream into one maximalist dessert, there may not be a flavor that can get the job done. This is a great option for serving at grown-up birthday parties where cake and ice cream served separately might be a bit much, but ice cream mashed up with cake is just right.
20. Dutch Chocolate
Imported cocoa helps give Dutch chocolate its status as one of the richest Blue Bell ice cream flavors. This is a decadent dipper for any chocolate lover to enjoy unadorned in a bowl or on a cone and the perfect way to experience the soothing simplicity of chocolate ice cream in its most agreeable form. However, if the temptation to get fancy is too strong, Dutch Chocolate can also serve as the perfect beginning to a banana split of epic proportions or a sundae with ambitions of being the greatest ice cream dessert ever.
21. Moo-llenium Crunch
There may not be a creation like Moo-llenium Crunch added to the collection of Blue Bell ice cream flavors for many years to come. Created as a celebration of the year 2000 arriving on schedule, the blend of dark chocolate and caramel chunks combined with roasted almonds, pecans and walnuts is just the sort of deconstructed candy bar essence an old-fashioned ice cream company needs to become a 21st-century favorite. It’s like someone grabbed handfuls of the best add-ins behind the counter and blitzed them into a melange of Blue Bell ice cream flavors to save you the trouble.
What Flavors of Ice Cream Does Blue Bell Have?
Blue Bell ice cream flavors offer a deep trove of decadent decision-making, ranging from the purist-tasting notes of Dutch Chocolate to the wild mix-in heavy imaginings of Strawberry Toaster Pastry. Though conceptualizing Blue Bell ice cream flavors list may be rooted in the simplest traditions of the dessert form, keeping up with contemporary tastes has pushed the company to toss in fun options like Tin Roof, Cotton Candy and Dr. Pepper Float to make sure fans always have something sweet to savor. While some are rotational Blue Bell ice cream flavors that only show up on occasion or during specific holiday seasons, there are more than enough enticing options to satisfy ice cream aficionados all year round.
Does Blue Bell Have Sugar-Free Ice Cream?
Among the deep treasury of Blue Bell ice cream flavors is a single sugar-free recipe, the very straightforward No Sugar Added Country Vanilla. It may be one of the more simplistic Blue Bell ice cream flavors, but it’s also a classic, and the healthiest ice cream for providing sugar-conscious ice cream fans a chance to indulge without compromising their dietary needs. It’s a great canvas for adding fresh fruit, toasted nuts or even sugar-free syrups to give the bowl a bit more magic.
Does Blue Bell Have Dairy-Free Ice Cream?
It may seem like a misstep, but among all the Blue Bell ice cream flavors, none are available in a dairy-free version. The company’s focus on traditional ice cream as a dairy-based product drives the use of milk and cream as base ingredients for every product. Though some ice cream companies provide sorbet as a dairy-free alternative to their ice creams, Blue Bell opts for a small selection of sherbets instead, all of which include milk as a core element.
The sheer selection of Blue Bell ice cream flavors makes ranking the best of the bunch a challenging task. There are no truly bad options, only preferences based on what you like better in your ice cream. As a company incorporates fruit, candy, dessert and beverage elements into its creations, Blue Bell works diligently to provide cartons customized for every appetite. But simply reading about Blue Bell ice cream flavors ranked against one another is no replacement for trying the flavors that sound most mouthwatering to determine for yourself which ones are best. Think of how sweet the research would be!
For even more ways to explore your favorite foods, check out other experiences happening on Cozymeal.
FOOD FOR THOUGHT?
Join the conversation.