16 Best Subway Sandwiches in 2025

Searching for the best Subway sandwiches you can try? With such an extensive menu, it can be easy to get lost in the sauce (and other ingredients!) of all the options. We’ve collected a list of Subway sandwiches ranked by popularity so you can get some solid leads on where to begin. 

In general, sandwiches can be a healthy choice. Of course, it’s important to be wary of the marketing that fast food brands, Subway included, use towards customers. A National Library of Medicine study from 2020 found that “health halo” and “health horn” effects are alive and well when we talk about different fast food brands. 

The study compares how people react to McDonald’s and Subway items, depending on the marketing angles they’re given (health vs. unhealthy). As always, it’s important to consider specific nutritional facts before choosing what you order. 

Jump to Section

• The 16 Best Subway Sandwiches Ranked
• What Is the Best Order at Subway?

The 16 Best Subway Sandwiches Ranked 

1. All-American Club 

If you’re looking for a classic American sandwich, the All-American Club is the one to go for. This is one of the best Subway sandwiches for those who like a little bit of everything, including lettuce, tomatoes, red onion, a slice of American cheese, mayonnaise and, of course, oven-roasted turkey, Black Forest ham and some crunchy bacon. The medley of meats harmonizes with the fresh vegetables, all of which get combined on fluffy Italian bread. 

This option is simply the best Subway order for those who love a classic, slightly elevated club sandwich. The three meats really work together to add that satisfying savory, crunchy texture. It’s a great option for bench-side lunches or picnics. 

2. Titan Turkey 

Sometimes you get a craving for shaved turkey that just doesn’t go away. Titan Turkey is one of the best Subway sandwiches to remedy that. As the name suggests, this is a beast of sandwich with more turkey than usual. It gets combined with smoky provolone cheese and refreshing vegetables like tomato, lettuce and onion. For sauce, the sandwich uses a healthy dose of mayonnaise spread throughout. 

Much like the All-American Club, this is another one of the best Subway sandwiches if you’re searching for a classic taste. The extra turkey definitely changes the experience a bit. It’s the kind of choice to go for when you’re feeling extra ravenous for turkey and all the fixings. 

3. The Ultimate B.M.T. 

A BLT? No, this next option is called the Ultimate B.M.T., more recently changed to the Italian B.M.T.  It stands for the “biggest, meatiest, tastiest” sandwich you’ll have. Historically, this one can be claimed as one of the best Subway sandwiches of all time. Its secure place on the menu for the last 40 years (since 1975!) proves its popularity. But what makes it so special? 

Well, as one of the best Subway sandwiches you can order, the ingredients are key. This one includes savory salami, spicy pepperoni and a reliable, slightly sweet ham. Add Provolone cheese, your classic vegetables along with a dash of Parmesan vinaigrette, and you’ve got one of the best Subway menu items to try, ready and waiting. 

4. Honey Mustard Chicken Wrap 

Some of the best Subway sandwiches are, in fact, wraps. The honey mustard chicken wrap is one of those occasions. Fresh and tender rotisserie chicken pieces are added to a bed of lettuce, tomatoes, red onions and shredded Monterey cheddar before getting topped with the chain’s signature honey mustard sauce. The sweetness and spiciness of the sauce pull everything together into a delicious sandwich. 

Interestingly enough, the popular sandwich chain changed its honey mustard recipe back in 2023. The initial change was met with tons of backlash and even a petition to reverse it. Today, many have become fans of the new rendition and it seems that others have made peace with it. Regardless, the honey mustard chicken wrap is one of the best Subway sandwiches on the menu today. Now, that’s a wrap. 

5. Hotshot Italiano 

Go for a taste of Italy, wherever you are. The Hotshot Italiano is one of the few Subway sandwiches ranked highly by customers who prefer spicy options. It comes with classic Italian ingredients like Genoa salami and pepperoni, along with jalapeño peppers, provolone cheese, lettuce, red onion, tomato and Parmesan vinaigrette. 

Every bite of this sandwich, one of the best Subway sandwiches on the menu, comes in hot and strong. The spicy flavors of the meats and jalapeño peppers are the star of the show, while the vegetables and plain Italian bread keep everything in balance. 

6. Elite Chicken Bacon Ranch 

This one’s for the ranch lovers out there. The Elite Chicken and Bacon Ranch sandwich is one of the best Subway sandwiches for those who like their sandwiches creamy and smooth. This combination is a chicken sandwich toasted with shredded Monterey cheddar cheese, bacon, vegetables and of course, a spicy peppercorn ranch. There’s just enough kick in the ranch sauce to wake you up without being too intense. 

This is one of the best Subway sandwiches to enjoy on its own or with a few additions according to your preference. Many say that the cheese and ranch mix well together. The final result is a pleasant savory experience. 

7. Turkey Bacon Avocado Wrap 

Winner, winner, turkey dinner. Our next pick when considering the best Subway sandwiches is the turkey bacon avocado wrap. It comes with smoky oven-roasted turkey slices, crispy bacon, smashed avocado and other vegetables. You’ll also taste Monterey cheddar cheese shreds and peppercorn ranch sauce in there. 

The main feature that makes this one of the best Subway sandwiches to try is the avocado and meats. The avocado adds a creamy factor to mitigate the potential dryness of the turkey. If you like this lesser-known option, consider checking out the Subway secret menu for more. 

8. The Beast 

Meat lovers, rejoice. The Beast is one of the best Subway sandwiches for those who love different kinds of meat and hate decisions. This hefty sandwich is made with half a pound of meats like pepperoni, salami, ham, turkey and roast beef, along with provolone cheese and classic vegetable toppings. As for condiments, you’ll taste mayonnaise as well as a refreshing Parmesan vinaigrette. 

The textures of this option make it one of the best Subway sandwiches for those who want a varied experience. You've got the softness of the hams and more as well as the crunch of lettuce and tomato, all within house-baked Italian bread. 

9. The Philly Steak & Cheese

If you’re craving a classic cheesesteak but too far from Philadelphia, The Philly is a great alternative for getting your fix. Out of many of the best Subway sandwiches, this one’s a unique option that takes its cues from a classic American sandwich. 

Subway’s version features a generous amount of shaved steak, American cheese slices, green pepper and red onion. It’s then topped with mayonnaise and comes together in a freshly baked Italian roll. Everything is toasted, making the cheese melt delectably. With rave reviews, it’s clear that this is the best order at Subway for many. 

10. Garlic Roast Beef 

This next option for those who want to try the best Subway sandwiches available today won’t disappoint. Subway’s garlic roast beef sandwich is part of its Subway Series, a collection of tried-and-true sub sandwiches inspired by baseball, America’s favorite pastime. 

A lot is going on in this one. Within fresh Italian bread is a centerpiece of thin roast beef slices and buttery provolone cheese, fresh lettuce, tomato and optional onion. It’s finished off with a delicious roasted garlic aioli with notes of herbs. This is definitely one of the best Subway sandwiches you can try if you want a change from the usual cold-cut-style ham sandwich options. 

11. Sweet Onion Chicken Teriyaki 

For chicken teriyaki in classic sandwich form, this is the one to choose. Also known as the All-Pro sweet onion chicken teriyaki, this option is one of the best Subway sandwiches if you want to veer away from most of the c

lassic cold ingredient combinations we’ve looked at so far. 

This is among the best Subway sandwiches that reinvent the wheel. For starters, it comes toasted on a wholesome multigrain bread. Inside, you’ll taste teriyaki chicken, American cheese, lettuce and tomato. The chicken is marinated in a sweet teriyaki sauce. Its strong flavor compliments the bread and background of other ingredients. 

12. The Outlaw 

Similar to The Philly mentioned earlier is The Outlaw. This is another one from the Subway Series collection, too. It’s one of the best Subway sandwiches to consider trying if you like spicy options. 

The Outlaw is a toasted sandwich that features a slew of shaved steak and pepperjack cheese, as well as green peppers and red onions sprinkled on top. Unlike The Philly, it substitutes mayonnaise with a Baja chipotle sauce that adds a delightful kick of spicy flavor that ties everything together seamlessly. This is among the best Subway sandwiches for many reasons, with the main one being its creative take on classic ingredients. 

13. Homestyle Chicken Salad Wrap 

If you like chicken salad, you’ll enjoy Subway’s homestyle chicken salad wrap. It’s the best Subway order for those who want something tasty, refreshing and filling, taking into account that wraps can be some of the healthiest items at Subway. This sandwich comes cold instead of toasted, making it great to bring along to outdoor adventures. 

If we’re talking ingredients, this sandwich features a light rotisserie chicken salad filling along with salad-inspired vegetables like spinach, tomatoes, lettuce, cucumbers and red onion. The main sauce is the mayonnaise in the salad, which is plenty. 

14. Home Run Ham 

Let’s take a return back to ham-filled classics. Home Run Ham is a fun option when it comes to the best Subway sandwiches that feature cold cuts of any kind. Notably, it features a whopping 33% more meat than its previous renditions. 

Along with a ton of soft, salty ham slices, the sandwich includes mayonnaise, lettuce, tomato and cheese. If you love ham and your only complaint for sandwiches is that there’s not more ham in them, this is one of the very best Subway sandwiches to try. The added protein will keep you full for longer as well, which is always an advantage for those on the go. 

15. Subway Club 

Turkey? Ham? Roast beef? How about all of the above? The Subway Club is an innovative sandwich that combines these three savory protein-filled ingredients on a wholesome heart-healthy multigrain bread, baked fresh in-house. For those who love a classic club sandwich, this is one of the best Subway sandwiches to go for. 

Along with meats and bread, the Subway Club also features American cheese, lettuce, tomato, red onion and mayonnaise. The mayonnaise and roast beef mingle well together, while the multigrain bread adds texture. Everything gets combined to create one of the best Subway sandwiches available today. 

16. Cold Cut Combo 

The last pick on our list is the cold-cut combo, a traditional sandwich option. It’s simple and reliable, which is why it’s one of the best Subway sandwiches you can choose. After all, there’s nothing like a soft, freshly baked Italian roll sliced and filled with ham, salami and Bologna slices. Toast it with or without cheese and top it with your choice of vegetables, like lettuce, tomato, pepper and onion, and you’ve got a winner that you simply can’t go wrong with. 

The simple ingredients of this option make it one of the best Subway sandwiches to bring on the go, either for a quick snack and energy boost or a full lunch meal. Since these ingredients are so light and fresh, the sandwich makes a great Subway breakfast option too. 

What Is the Best Order at Subway?

There are so many options when it comes to choosing the best Subway sandwiches to try, but which ones are the best? The answer is subjective and depends on a person’s unique tastes and preferences. Some might be looking for healthier options compared to other fast foods. Others might want spicy options or meat-free alternatives. Factors like these are endless and often constantly changing, making it hard to pin down the single best Subway sandwich to enjoy. 

Still, we’ve narrowed it down to the most popular contenders. These are the best Subway menu items currently available right now. But the chain introduces new combinations and styles of sandwiches often, so it might be worth your time to keep an eye out for the next best order. 

The extensive menu of pre-made combinations and substitutes makes for a fun challenge to explore and discover the best Subway sandwiches to enjoy. Out of many of the best Subway menu items, there’s sure to be something for everyone. All it takes is a few tries to find the item that speaks best to you. 

Of course, with delicious ingredients and freshly baked bread, it’s hard to go wrong. Consider what you know you like and then go from there. Before you know it, you’re sure to find your next favorite Subway sandwich. 

For even more ways to explore your favorite foods, check out other experiences happening on Cozymeal.