11 Best Natural Peanut Butter Brands To Try in 2025
What makes the best natural peanut butter? Not only should it contain limited ingredients and be free from additives and preservatives, such as palm oil, but the best natural peanut butter should also taste delicious.
Conveniently, many brands are now available that are certified non-GMO and made from organic ingredients, often with a focus on sustainability. To help make discovering these brands easy, we’ve investigated a range of the best natural peanut butter choices on the market to bring you a selection of our favorites.
Some are crunchy, some are smooth, but we’ve made sure to uncover a diversity of flavors and textures for those who want to use peanut butter for cooking or spoon straight from the jar. There are also options to suit all budgets and we’ve included varieties available at grocery stores and online.
If you’re looking to eat a little cleaner, keep reading to discover the 11 best all-natural peanut butter brands.
Jump to Section
The 11 Best All-Natural Peanut Butter Brands
1. Fix & Fogg Smooth Peanut Butter
An award-winning brand with an emphasis on pushing boundaries, Fix & Fogg takes the number one spot in our look at the best natural peanut butter. Each jar contains just two ingredients — high oleic peanuts from the Córdoba region of Argentina and a pinch of salt from the company’s native New Zealand.
All Fix and Fogg peanut butters are certified non-GMO, palm oil free and vegan. The minimal ingredient formula also means this peanut butter works in a range of recipes, from dipping sauces for healthy rice paper summer rolls to gluten-free peanut butter cookies. This brand of peanut butter is even the one served on the International Space Station!
2. Smucker’s Organic Creamy Peanut Butter
If you’re looking for the best organic peanut butter with no added salt, then Smucker’s Organic Creamy Peanut Butter could be a top choice. It’s technically a creamy peanut butter, but a looser grind means that it retains some bite, perfect for those who appreciate a little texture. A crunchy version with larger chunks of nuts is available too.
Each jar of Smucker’s is made with 99% fresh-roasted peanuts and a dash of salt. There are no sweeteners or other additives such as palm oil. Smucker’s is also very spreadable, making it one of the best natural peanut butters to use in sandwiches or for dipping.
3. Spread the Love NAKED Organic Peanut Butter
Certified organic and containing only a single ingredient, Spread the Love is a great pick to get the title of best natural peanut butter. The original recipe was developed by the founders as a gift for friends and family, but it grew so much in popularity that a national brand was born.
These days, every jar contains only ethically sourced peanuts from North America, which are used to craft small batches of this pick for the best organic natural peanut butter.
This creamy, minimal ingredient peanut butter also works in many recipes, from savory dishes to relatively healthy sweets like chickpea cookie dough or sweet potato brownies.
4. 365 Organic Creamy Peanut Butter
Calling all celery spreaders and apple dippers! 365 Organic Creamy Peanut Butter is excellent for making your favorite healthy snacks. It’s also one of the best organic peanut butter options, with no GMO ingredients, a creamy taste and easy spreadability.
One of 365’s best-selling products, this peanut butter is available in a creamy variety, the most versatile option, as well as crunchy. The creamy version doesn’t contain any added sugar or salt, allowing the taste of the peanuts to shine.
365’s offering is notably one of the most accessible and reasonably priced among these picks for the best natural peanut butter.
5. Field Day Organic Smooth & Unsalted Peanut Butter
Organic and non-GMO, Field Day offers a very smooth addition to our list of the best natural peanut butter. The texture is finer than other entries here, so we found that this was a solid choice for use in cooking.
There’s no added sugar in Field Day's peanut butter, but it has a slightly sweet flavor from the roasted peanuts. Even better, it’s packaged in a BPA-free plastic jar. This natural peanut butter is a fab choice to use on toast with some healthy bread. For those looking for more bite, Field Day also has a crunchy version.
6. Trader Joe’s: Creamy, Salted Peanut Butter
Regularly named as the best natural peanut butter for those on a budget, Trader Joe’s Creamy Salted spread contains only salt and peanuts. These peanuts are roasted with their skins on to increase flavor, making this one of the best-tasting natural peanut butter choices for spreading on toast or using in savory recipes like chicken satay.
This healthy snack at Trader Joe’s, in common with the other additions to our list, is free from palm oil. That means some oil separation may occur, so give it a good stir before enjoying.
7. Laura Scudder’s All-Natural Smooth Peanut Butter
GMO-free and containing only organic ingredients, Laura Scudder’s is one of the best organic natural peanut butter brands. It’s made with 99% peanuts and a small amount of salt to help bring out the natural flavor of the peanuts. This natural peanut butter also comes in a glass jar, which can be recycled.
We’ve included the lightly salted, All Natural Laura Scudder’s on our rundown of the best natural peanut butter, but you’ll also find an unsalted creamy version, which is good for those looking to reduce their dietary sodium. Every jar is also completely gluten-free, making it perfect for almost all consumers.
8. Adams Natural Crunchy Peanut Butter
Another versatile pick of the best natural peanut butter, Adams is an affordable spread that comes in a recyclable glass jar. It’s also available in a range of sizes, so it's convenient for taking on vacation or slipping into your desk drawer for a snack at work.
Adams Natural Crunchy Peanut Butter is free from added sugar, preservatives and stabilizers. It’s also made from just two ingredients: peanuts and a small amount of salt. We think this is one of the best natural crunchy peanut butter choices, but you’ll also find a creamy version if you prefer something smoother.
9. Crazy Richard’s 100% Peanuts
If you’re seeking the best-tasting peanut butter made from a single ingredient, then Crazy Richard’s 100% Peanuts could be the jar for you. Available in creamy and crunchy varieties, Crazy Richard’s is versatile enough to use in many recipes.
However, some reviewers of this natural peanut butter have noted that it can get a little runny when left out, so you might want to pop it in the refrigerator to make it easier to spread.
10. Georgia Grinders Creamy Peanut Butter
Hand-crafted Georgia Grinders Creamy Peanut Butter is a non-GMO spread with a delicious flavor. We love the smooth texture, which makes this one of the best natural peanut butter choices to use in recipes such as dipping sauces and peanut curries. It can also be used for spreading on crackers or as part of a healthy snack for kids, like peanut butter and jelly sandwiches or ants on a log.
In common with other entries on our list of the best natural peanut butter, Georgia Grinders' hand-crafted spread contains only peanuts and salt. It also comes in a glass jar, which is easy to recycle.
11. MaraNatha Organic Crunchy Peanut Butter
Perfect to pair with celery, dark chocolate or healthy fruits like apple slices, MaraNatha is one of the best all-natural, crunchy peanut butter options. It’s made from peanuts only, which are roasted in small batches to intensify their flavor. The peanuts then go through a double grinding process for a silky smooth texture before larger chunks of nuts are added to create the crunch.
In common with most of the best natural peanut butters in our guide, MaraNatha is certified organic and non-GMO. The creamy version can be subject to oil separation, but the company also produces several no-stir options.
What Is the Best Natural Peanut Butter?
Peanut butter is a fantastic choice of snack for kids and adults. It can be spread onto apple slices or healthy vegetables like celery sticks, used as a dip or added to smoothies — a great choice when looking for healthy and simple breakfast food ideas.
Not only is the best natural peanut butter versatile, but it also offers a wide assortment of health benefits. It’s high in fiber and protein, so it can help you feel fuller for longer. In addition, choosing the healthiest peanut butter can add a range of essential vitamins and minerals to your diet, including vitamin E, B vitamins, calcium and iron.
A study conducted in 2021 and published by The National Library of Medicine also concluded that eating a regular serving of peanuts, especially in the form of the best natural peanut butter, can improve memory. This study also suggested that peanut butter is a food that relieves stress, making it a great snack food to turn to when you have a busy week at work.
The best natural peanut butter for you depends on how you’re planning to use it. Choices such as Trader Joe’s are a fantastic all-rounder, while Fix and Fogg’s peanut butter makes a great topping for toast as an evening snack. Georgia Grinders is a top pick for use in cooking, while Laura Scudder’s is one of our favorites for dipping fruit and vegetables.
When deciding between the best natural peanut butter, you should opt for brands that contain very limited ingredients. Crazy Richard’s, for example, contains peanuts only, which are specially roasted to enhance their flavor.
Some types, such as MaraNatha, even use a small batch roasting technique to really increase the peanut flavor. If you’re trying to reduce sodium in your diet, then these jars are good choices too, as they contain no salt. Other additions to our list of the best-tasting natural peanut butter, such as Smucker’s, include just a small amount of salt to enhance the flavor.
Whether you love spreading it on crackers or using it as a dip for crisp apple slices, peanut butter is a popular and adaptable snack. However you enjoy it, you should aim to use the best natural peanut butter you can find.
The options we’ve outlined here contain no artificial ingredients, only peanuts and a little salt. Each one has a unique taste and texture, but any one of the best natural peanut butters in our guide is a great choice for those looking to maximize its health benefits.
For even more ways to explore your favorite foods, check out other experiences happening on Cozymeal.
FOOD FOR THOUGHT?
Join the conversation.