23 Best Costco Desserts for All Occasions in 2025
When it comes to satisfying your sweet tooth at the end of a meal, finding the best Costco dessert can feel like a mission you might not want to undertake. From towers of assorted chocolates to trays of delicate Italian desserts, Costco’s dessert selection has something for every craving.
Whether you’re planning a celebration, searching for the perfect gift or simply want to treat yourself, there’s a standout dessert waiting for you. But should you go for the classic cheesecake or pie, a tray of make-at-home cookies or a box of assorted truffles?
To help narrow down the selection, we’re going through the best Costco desserts to buy, including party treats, mini desserts, dessert trays and more. So, keep reading to discover your next sweet treat from this popular bulk retailer.
Jump to Section
The 23 Best Desserts at Costco
1. Classic Cake Tiramisù Cake
This popular Costco tiramisù dessert is a mix of the classic Italian dessert and a cake. It features layers of ladyfingers soaked in rich coffee syrup, plenty of vanilla-flavored mascarpone mousse and a delicate dusting of cocoa powder on top.
Pre-cut into 14 slices, this is one of the best Costco desserts for party convenience and indulgence, as all you need to do is transfer the portions to plates and serve.
The traditional flavors of a tiramisù cake aren’t for everyone, but nonetheless, its creamy texture and balanced sweetness make it one of the best Costco desserts when you want show-stopping dinner party ideas to end a meal. The Kirkland Signature Tiramisù Scoop Cake is another great pick if the Classic Cake version is not available.
2. DeMilan Panettone Tin
Some of the best desserts at Costco bring a taste of regional culinary traditions to your post-dinner spread and that’s the case with this Italian dessert. A panettone is a traditional Milanese sweet bread, often gifted around Italian holidays and the festive season. These days, its appeal has stretched outside of Italy, becoming one of the most popular Christmas foods around the world.
This specific panettone from DeMilan stands out among the best Costco desserts for its traditional flavor and quality ingredients. The “low bake” shape is a hallmark of Milanese panettone and this moist cake is littered with well-distributed candied fruits.
With a light and airy texture, it’s a versatile dessert that can be served on its own or used in other dessert recipes like panettone French toast or bread pudding.
3. David's Cookies Brownie and Cookie Combo Pack
This brownie and cookie combo pack from David’s Cookies is the ultimate party food for kids and adults alike. This delightful mixed pack includes six rocky road brownies and 12 chocolate chunk cookies.
The brownies are filled to the brim with walnuts, chocolate chips, peanut butter chips and a chocolate ganache drizzle, while the cookies are perfectly cooked with an even distribution of chocolate.
The only drawback to this combo pack is that, because they are stored together, the cookies can get broken during transport. On the bright side, it’s both a testament to their crumbly and soft texture and the dense decadence of the brownies.
These are also some of the best Costco frozen desserts for saving for later — you can freeze the cookies and brownies for up to six months with no loss in texture or flavor. While you may not think the cookies from the Costco food court menu can be topped, these sweet treats come pretty close!
4. Mary Macleod's All Butter Shortbread Cookie Jars
Mary Macleod's offers all-butter shortbread cookies in two flavors: Classic and Chocolate Crunch. If you love to have a buttery and crumbly biscuit to round out the end of a meal, this might be the best Costco dessert for you.
This woman-owned business has been making shortbread for over 40 years and it shows in the quality and care put into their products. Packaged in elegant, reusable glass jars with satin ribbons, this two-pack makes for a delightful gift or a personal treat.
It's also quite a substantial purchase, with roughly 64 shortbread cookies in each jar. As far as the best Costco dessert cookies go, these shortbread cookies are authentic, crowd-pleasing and downright delicious.
5. Austin Cake Ball Catering Assortment
The Austin Cake Ball Catering Assortment is all you need when you’re looking for the best Costco dessert that caters to a large crowd. This set includes 12 each of red velvet, salted caramel, birthday cake and Oreo-flavored cake balls.
Each ball is made of a truffle-sized cake that is dipped and decorated. They’re a dense and flavorful treat that is perfect for any event, from a birthday party to a corporate mixer.
Best enjoyed at room temperature to slightly soften them, these bite-sized desserts can also be refrigerated for up to two weeks if you like to plan party menus in advance. If you want a dessert that has variety, this is the best Costco dessert for you.
6. Ferrara Bakery Plain and Hand Dipped Belgian Chocolate Filled Cannoli
Ferrara Bakery, established in 1892, is one of the best Costco dessert brands to opt for if you want authentic Sicilian pastries. With this large cannoli assortment, you get 24 cannoli. Each one features a light and crispy shell filled with sweet ricotta cream and 12 of the cannoli are also hand-dipped in rich Belgian chocolate.
These sweet Sicilian food treats are supposed to be crisp and crunchy, so it’s important to consume them within two hours of thawing. This might not be ideal if you’re planning corporate event entertainment or other gatherings where the desserts may sit out for extended periods.
Nevertheless, their traditional flavor and the legacy of Ferrara Bakery make these cannoli one of the most popular desserts for enjoying a taste of Italy no matter where you are in the world.
7. Collin Street Bakery Mini Pecan Cake Bundle
If you can’t decide what flavor is your favorite — or you’re catering to a wide variety of flavor preferences at a party or gathering — products like the Collin Street Bakery mini cake bundle are the best Costco dessert options to go for. This bundle offers a sampling of four of the brand’s popular mini pecan cakes: DeLuxe Fruitcake, Pineapple, Texas Blonde and Cherry Fudge.
Each cake features Texas pecans and is hand-decorated and presented in cute collectible tins. Unopened, they remain fresh at room temperature for up to three months. These mini pecan cakes are among the best Costco desserts for gifting to your loved ones before the festive season, so when the holidays roll around, they’ve got their dessert options covered.
8. Godiva and More Tower
When you need a selection of sweet treats that will blow all the other gifts out of the water, this is the best Costco dessert on this list. The Godiva and More Tower features a luxurious assortment of chocolates and treats, including Godiva Masterpieces and chocolate brownies by Baker Brothers.
Packed in an elegant four-tier set of boxes with a satin ribbon, the presentation is just as show-stopping as the flavors. Just a few of the treats you'll get include milk chocolate hazelnut oysters, dark chocolate ganache hearts and milk chocolate caramel lions.
A chocolate sauce soufflé cake, St. Germain palmiers and a milk chocolate truffle bar with a caramel filling are also included. If you need desserts that double as a beautifully presented gift, this is the best Costco dessert you can get.
9. David's Cookies Butter Pecan Meltaways
It can be hard to shop for people during the fall season if they don’t like pumpkin-flavored treats, but the best Costco desserts aren’t made with pumpkin; they’re made with pecans!
Serve these Butter Pecan Meltaways from David’s Cookies as part of your Thanksgiving dessert table, gift them to your loved one or simply enjoy them in a quiet corner with a warm cup of hot chocolate.
These melt-in-your-mouth cookies are made with pure, creamy butter and a generous amount of pecan chunks before being dusted with delicately sweet powdered sugar. With each 32-ounce tin containing around 64 cookies, they’re ideal for enjoying throughout the festive season.
10. Mediterranean Handmade Baklava Gift Pack
If you believe that the best Costco desserts are the ones that are buttery, sweet and layered with chopped nuts, then this baklava assortment is right up your street. Each pack includes six different types of this beloved sweet Greek food, filled with nuts like pistachios, almonds and cashews and drizzled with honey to finish.
Handmade in Dubai, this two-pack is both Kosher and Halal certified. Some people find the baklava to be sweeter than they expect, but its rich nutty flavors and flaky texture secure its spot in the running for the title of best Costco dessert.
11. David's Cookies Gourmet Chocolate Chunk Frozen Cookie Dough
Another popular offering from David’s Cookies is this 90-piece gourmet chocolate chunk cookie dough, which probably takes the cake (or the cookie) for the best Costco dessert that you can make yourself. With the dough pre-formed into the perfect cookie size, all you have to do is heat your oven, place the frozen cookie dough on a cookie sheet and bake until perfect.
Nothing quite beats the taste of homemade cookies and these get you all that flavor with none of the hassle. While most of the best Costco frozen desserts are pre-made, these cookies are the ideal emergency dessert that you can pull out at a moment’s notice and create something delicious.
12. Collin Street Bakery Cake Bites Bundle, DeLuxe Fruitcake and Pineapple Pecan Cake
When you can’t decide which flavor is better between the DeLuxe Fruitcake and the Pineapple Pecan Cake, just get both. The cake bites bundle from Collin Street Bakery is the best of both worlds and this is one of the best Costco desserts you can buy if you’re a die-hard fruitcake and pecan cake fan.
Each box contains 12 bites of each flavor, making a total of 24 bite-sized treats for you to decide whether or not to share. These cakes are made from the same recipes as the full-sized counterparts and each treat is finished with the bakery’s signature honey glaze.
Their convenient size makes them the best Costco dessert for almost any occasion, from a little post-dinner treat to a fully-fledged dessert offering at your next work function or celebration.
13. Ethel M Chocolates Truffles Collection
Sometimes just saying “I love you” isn’t enough; sometimes you need to show your love with chocolate truffles! If you’re looking for the best Costco dessert to show someone you care about them, this 24-piece truffle collection is the one.
Featuring decadent flavors like dark chocolate, 100% Kona espresso, white chocolate, milk chocolate and cinnamon pecan ganache, there’s a favorite flavor for everyone. Hand-brushed with cocoa butter, these small-batch gifts are the best Costco desserts you can get if you need something reliable that will cater to different palates.
The best part? This is a two-pack, so you can give one to a loved one and savor the other all to yourself.
14. Sweet Celebration Gift Tower
It can be hard to know what someone’s favorite Costco desserts are if you’ve never shopped at Costco with them. On occasions like this, the Sweet Celebration Gift Tower is a solid choice.
It’s a six-tier golden tower filled with a variety of popular sweets from well-known brands, from Lindt Lindor to Guylian. This sweet pick is essentially a variety tower of the best Costco desserts.
Inside, you’ll find milk chocolate truffles, dark chocolate ganache truffless, milk chocolate caramel lions and milk chocolate hazelnut oysters, plus dark chocolate ganache hearts, milk truffles and traditional truffles. St. Germain palmiers, vanilla and cocoa-coated wafers, various flavors of waffles, hazelnut rolled wafer cookies and crème cookies round out the tempting selection.
15. David’s Cookies Premier Chocolate Cake
When you need birthday cake ideas that steal the spotlight, the Premier Chocolate Cake from David’s Cookies is the best Costco dessert for the job. It features four layers of rich chocolate cake with a smooth milk chocolate mousse between each layer. The cake is then enveloped in a luscious chocolate ganache before being adorned with dark chocolate bark pieces as the finishing touch.
This cake can be easily divided into 14 slices, making it both generous and convenient. The cake is also OU-D-Certified kosher, contains no added preservatives and is praised in online reviews for its rich flavor and moist texture. Among the best Costco desserts on this list, this chocolate cake is one of the best for gatherings and parties, as every guest can get a satisfying slice.
16. The Cake Bake Shop Carrot Cake
Carrot cake: you either love it or hate it. For the lovers, this carrot cake from The Cake Bake Shop is the best Costco dessert you’ll ever buy!
Serving between 16 and 22 guests, this moist and spiced carrot cake is made from freshly grated carrots and plenty of cinnamon. You won’t find any nuts and raisins in this cake, instead, the fluffy cake pieces are stacked with the bakery’s signature cream cheese frosting between each layer and covered with vanilla buttercream.
The best Costco desserts are ones that last, and this cake is known for its generous size, meaning you'll have plenty to enjoy for yourself after the party has finished.
17. Ferrara Bakery Rainbow Cookies
Ferrara Bakery, a fifth-generation family-owned establishment from NYC's Little Italy, offers its traditional rainbow cookies as one of the best Costco desserts available to purchase online. These tricolor treats consist of almond and macaroon paste cake layers, which are sandwiched with zesty apricot jam and coated in decadent chocolate on either end.
If you or someone you know loves nostalgic treats, these rainbow cookies might be the best Costco dessert to opt for. They’re soft, sweet and slightly fruity, and they’re so popular that they’re made in-house daily using a secret recipe that Antonio Ferrara created when he opened the bakery in the late 1800s.
18. Godiva Belgian Heritage Collection Chocolate Gift Box
This 15-piece gift box showcases all the best flavors that Godiva has to offer. With chocolates like the Ruby G Cube, Croconoir and White Chocolate Heart, this is one of the best Costco dessert options for gifting something elegant and indulgent to your friends, coworkers and family.
While the assortment is praised for its variety, some feel that the smaller size of the chocolates doesn’t justify the price. However, with Belgian heritage at the core of the collection, the luxurious taste and packaging make it a notable mention among the best Costco desserts.
19. The Fruit Company Covered Bridge Gourmet Gift Box
For those who may not like the other sugar-laden options on this list of the best Costco desserts, The Fruit Company's Gourmet Gift Box is sure to appeal.
This curated selection of sweet and savory flavors includes Pacific Northwest-grown fruits like green Anjou pears, red Anjou pears and Honeycrisp apples alongside beef summer sausage, crackers, chipotle cheddar cheese and chocolate-covered cherries.
It’s the ideal gift for those on a low refined sugar diet or people who just prefer things a little less sweet. The combination of fresh fruits and gourmet Costco snacks makes it the perfect at-home sweet and savory dessert platter. While it’s an unconventional choice for the best Costco dessert, if you’re always opting for the cheese platter on a restaurant’s dessert menu, you’ll love this.
20. Ferrara Bakery New York Cheesecake
Another choice from Ferrara Bakery in the running for the title of best Costco dessert is the New York cheesecake two-pack. Each eight-inch cheesecake serves 10 to 12 people. It’s made fresh with a smooth and indulgent cream cheese filling atop a traditional graham cracker crust.
Each cheesecake can be refrigerated for up to four days, or it can also be frozen for up to six months, offering flexibility for any occasion when the best Costco desserts are needed. These cheesecakes also arrive with no decorations, so they’re the ideal blank canvas for adding berries, edible flowers or chocolate decorations.
21. Kirkland Signature Pumpkin Pie
This next Costco dessert is a seasonal treat that draws a lot of online attention when it’s available in-store. Some swear it’s the best pumpkin dessert they’ve had, while others think it misses the mark, preferring a homemade pumpkin pie.
Despite the mixed views, this pick for the best Costco dessert is relatively simple: a buttery crust is filled with a creamy and well-spiced pumpkin custard. A notable point is that this Costco dessert is made from scratch, in-house, each day. It pairs perfectly with whipped cream or ice cream but is also delicious on its own.
With a highly affordable price (the whole pie often costs under $6, cementing Costco’s place as one of the cheapest grocery stores), it’s easy to try it yourself and make a final decision on whether you rate this as one of the best Costco desserts.
22. Kirkland Signature Apple Berry Pie
Most of us can relate to that feeling of utter horror when you’ve forgotten you’re supposed to be bringing the dessert to your friend’s fall gathering this evening. In a pinch, this Kirkland Signature pie is the best Costco dessert you can order when looking for last-minute potluck ideas that everyone will love.
With same-day delivery, this apple and berry pie is made fresh and combines apples, strawberries and raspberries within a perfectly flaky pie crust. There’s nothing quite as nostalgic as the sweet and tart flavors used in this dessert.
The generous fruit content and high-quality crust keep it among the best Costco desserts that can be eaten solo, but it’s made even better with a scoop of vanilla ice cream. If berry fillings aren’t your thing, the Homestyle Apple Pie is also a highly recommended Costco dessert, however, some stores only sell this around Thanksgiving.
23. Kirkland Signature Pecan Pie
Kirkland does pies well and another beloved seasonal treat is the Kirkland Signature Pecan Pie. While available all year in some locations, most Costco stores will have this pie available throughout the Thanksgiving period.
Made in-house daily, it features a decadent and buttery crust filled with a rich caramel and pecan filling. While perfectly fine on its own, it’s almost definitely made better with a creamy scoop of ice cream.
What Are the Best Costco Desserts for a Party?
A great party dessert needs to be both delicious and easy to serve. When choosing the best Costco dessert for a gathering, consider whole cakes that have pre-measured slices, pre-cut dessert trays or bite-sized treats that guests can grab without much fuss.
Larger options like layer cakes offer a show-stopping centerpiece, while trays packed with assorted flavors let everyone find something they love. Mini desserts and variety packs are also excellent choices, allowing guests to sample different flavors without committing to a full slice.
Whether you opt for creamy cheesecakes, flaky pastries or rich chocolate brownies, the best Costco dessert for a party is ultimately one that keeps guests coming back for more.
What Are the Best Costco Mini Desserts?
For those who prefer their sweets in smaller bites, Costco offers a variety of mini desserts that don’t compromise on flavor. Among the best Costco mini desserts are David's Cookies Butter Pecan Meltaways, which melt in your mouth with a buttery richness and are the ideal size for grabbing two, three...or four.
Other top contenders include Ferrara’s Bakery Rainbow Cookies, a nostalgic tri-color treat with layers of almond cake and chocolate, and the Austin Cake Ball Catering Assortment, featuring an array of indulgent flavors.
Finally, if you love warm, freshly baked cookies, David's Cookies Gourmet Chocolate Chunk Frozen Cookie Dough is a fantastic choice. Whether for a gathering or solo indulgence, these mini treats make it easy to enjoy the best Costco desserts while having enough to save some for later.
What Are the Best Costco Dessert Trays?
If you're looking for a dessert that’s both visually impressive and effortlessly shareable, Costco’s dessert trays are a top pick. The best Costco dessert trays offer pre-sliced convenience, making them ideal for events, office parties or family gatherings. A standout option is the tiramisù cake, which features layers of espresso-soaked ladyfingers and velvety mascarpone mousse.
Another great choice is the Classic Cake Limoncello Quarter Sheet Cake, which comes pre-cut into 14 slices and delivers a refreshing citrus twist. With these options, serving the best Costco dessert becomes a stress-free experience and every guest can easily grab a perfectly portioned slice of sweetness.
With so many mouthwatering options to choose from, finding the best Costco dessert can become an exciting challenge. Whether you’re in the mood for a rich chocolate cake, a jar of moreish cookies or a box of bite-sized pastries, Costco has something for every occasion. No matter your preference, the best Costco desserts are ones that bring joy with every bite.
For even more ways to explore your favorite foods, check out other experiences happening on Cozymeal.
FOOD FOR THOUGHT?
Join the conversation.